Customer reviews

Customer Reviews | 19 reviews | 2.7 out of 5

2.5 stars

19 reviews | 2.7 out of 5

2.5 stars

19 reviews | 2.7 out of 5

Would recommend to a friend
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 stars
1-18 of 18 total reviews
Would recommend to a friend



Best Non-automatic Lip Liner

Customer review by Butterdaisy

5.0 stars 7/27/2012 by Butterdaisy
by Butterdaisy

Bought this in 2 colors and love it! Definitely going to buy more. Also wanted to mention that this sharpened easily with 2 different sharpeners I used including a cheap ELF cosmetics sharpener. I prefer automatic, but this is definitely a winner.

columbia, sc
Would recommend to a friend? Yes
Lip Perfection

Customer review by Jenni4

5.0 stars 5/7/2011 by Jenni4
by Jenni4

I love the new formula. It's softer, and more youthful looking. It also helps my lipstick last longer. (it works really well with the Lip Perfection lipstick) Change is good.

Pasadena, TX
Would recommend to a friend? Yes
Best Quality at Half the Price!

Customer review by AmyJ

4.0 stars 11/1/2011 by AmyJ
by AmyJ

I absolutely love these lip liners! Having tried many different brands at all price points, the LipPerfection liners are the best quality I've found. My only wish is that more colors are coming; that would change my rating from 4 to 5 stars!

Arlington, TX
Would recommend to a friend? Yes
Solution to sharpening

Customer review by SallyJo

4.0 stars 11/10/2013 by SallyJo
by SallyJo

. Break off the bottom end of liner.. Cut off one end of a Q-Tip and use the stick to push up the liner a little at a time . It works, and no need to carry around an extra sharpener. When one Q-Tip gets too short, I just make a new "push-stick" ;-)

Kure Beach
Would recommend to a friend? Yes

Customer review by franktank

4.0 stars 3/9/2011 by franktank
by franktank

I got the colors smoky and passion, and i love passion for a bright lip color! goes on very very smooth! Smoky is cute but it makes my lips look dull. just the wrong color for me, i will buy others to try though!

Green Bay, WI
Would recommend to a friend? Yes
Wish there were more colors!

Customer review by TiffanyC

4.0 stars 7/9/2011 by TiffanyC
by TiffanyC

Moisturizing and smooth. I really like this! I see that Cover Girl comes out with so many fun and vibrant colors for eye products, and it would be great to see them come out with more than just natural color selections for lip liners too!

Reston, VA
Would recommend to a friend? Yes
Great feel!

Customer review by HBJan98

4.0 stars 4/19/2015 by HBJan98
by HBJan98

First lip liner I've ever bought and I love what it does for me and my lipsticks. I did take the advice of another reviewer and popped the bottom off and used a q-tip to push it up and put it back on.

Huntington Beach
Would recommend to a friend? Yes
Skin type:Combination

Customer review by JodyfromNorthridge

3.0 stars 2/28/2011 by JodyfromNorthridge
by JodyfromNorthridge

I tried Smoky & Seduce. Seduce didn't show up even on my light skin. It felt smooth and the quality is good. I really miss the retractable Outlast Lipliners! Especially the Spice shade which CG didn't add to the new line up. They're just ok.

Northridge, CA
Would recommend to a friend? Yes
215 disaster

Customer review by msles1stlouismo

3.0 stars 1/7/2012 by msles1stlouismo
by msles1stlouismo

reading this review,it seems like everybody incuding myself loves the product,but if i new that finding a sharpener would be difficult i would not had gotten this product,covergirl needs to really be on top of this product,this product is not cheap!

st louis
Would recommend to a friend? No
I miss Outlast Smoothwear #150 Spice!!

Customer review by Mahilani

3.0 stars 6/2/2011 by Mahilani
by Mahilani

I wore Spice Outlast Smoothwear for years & absolutely loved it - great color, price & product overall!! I've tried 3 of NEW colors & none are close. Please bring back SPICE. Also not a fan of sharpening...bring back the retractables, too, please.

Glendora, CA
Would recommend to a friend? Yes
Waste of Product

Customer review by Jelli

1.0 stars 7/29/2013 by Jelli
by Jelli

The color is good, but it bleeds outside of the ridge of the lip.The problem comes once the tip runs to the plastic. After using 2 sharpeners, the best you can get is a blunt tip which falls off and if you try warming it, it will ignite.Never again.

Las Vegas, NV
Would recommend to a friend? No

Customer review by Nannette

1.0 stars 3/9/2013 by Nannette
by Nannette

Amazed that there is no way to advance the lipstick in this lipliner.Very disappointed that it requires a special sharpener, availability unknown.Wasted money on 3 of these lipliners.

Shreveport, La.
Would recommend to a friend? Yes
No way to sharpen it

Customer review by Doblin

1.0 stars 3/10/2012 by Doblin
by Doblin

I love the color. It is impossible to sharpen the liner. I cannot get the lip color to come out of the stick. Therefore, it was a BIG waste of money.

Beaumont, Texas
Would recommend to a friend? No
Does not even come close to Outlast

Customer review by nomoreofthis

1.0 stars 6/24/2011 by nomoreofthis
by nomoreofthis

I LOVED Outlast lipliner! This one is not good at all. It is so light it can hardly be seen when applying. In addition, it comes off so easy! Please, please, please bring back the Outlast Lip Liner! Why mess with something that worked soooooo well?

New Iberia, LA
Would recommend to a friend? No
Not your Outlast Smoothwear!

Customer review by Mara628

1.0 stars 4/27/2011 by Mara628
by Mara628

I was using the Outlast Smoothwear (in spice) forever - it was the perfect color and texture for the best price! But the Lip Perfection Lipliner is NOT the same. The smoky intense color barely shows up at all! I miss Outlast Smoothwear in spice!

Los Angeles, CA
Would recommend to a friend? No
Liked it, but

Customer review by CharlieS

1.0 stars 5/3/2012 by CharlieS
by CharlieS

I bought the first one, liked it; used the little nub on top and then tried to roll it up to get more. It wouldn't roll. That was it. I liked it so I bought another. Same thing. If that's all I get, I can't afford it.

Graham, Texas
Would recommend to a friend? No

Customer review by WSinNY

1.0 stars 4/25/2011 by WSinNY
by WSinNY

Wish I had seen some of these reviews earlier. Bought Smokey... it bleeds onto the edge of my lip, however the color is barely noticeable...just enough to make you look as though your makeup is smudged. Wish the other retractable lip liner was back!

Beacon, NY
Would recommend to a friend? No
Can't find sharpener to work with product

Customer review by Smoore

1.0 stars 5/13/2011 by Smoore
by Smoore

I like the product itself, it goes on smoothly and I love the color Beloved. I can't seem to find a sharpener to work on this pencil. So I only get about 5-6 uses out of the pencil and then I have to buy a new one. Any help on a sharpener?

Louisville, Kentucky
Would recommend to a friend? No