Walmart+ helps you save more time & money this holiday. Learn more.
Walmart+ helps you save more time & money this holiday.

Customer reviews & ratings

3.9
Average Rating:(3.9)out of 5 stars
1722 ratings
89%Recommended(17 of 19)
5 stars
627
4 stars
545
3 stars
321
2 stars
153
1 star
76
5 stars
627
4 stars
545
3 stars
321
2 stars
153
1 star
76
Most helpful positive review
Average Rating:(5.0)out of 5 stars
My favorite eyeshadow right now
Love the sparkling peach color! This is my favorite eye shadow right now. It is so easy to apply on the way out the door when I don't have a lot of “mirror time” in the mornings! A few quick swipes and it wears all day long. I originally loved the matte color, but then I got kinda hooked on the sparkling one recently. This is my second purchase of this remarkable product.
Most helpful negative review
Average Rating:(2.0)out of 5 stars
Dark, gloppy
Much much much darker than expected very heavy on the lid. I was looking for a creamy stick not actual paint on goo. Not fun trying to get it off just a bad idea all around just give me a cream stick please please please please please
Most helpful positive review
Average Rating:(5.0)out of 5 stars
My favorite eyeshadow right now
Love the sparkling peach color! This is my favorite eye shadow right now. It is so easy to apply on the way out the door when I don't have a lot of “mirror time” in the mornings! A few quick swipes and it wears all day long. I originally loved the matte color, but then I got kinda hooked on the sparkling one recently. This is my second purchase of this remarkable product.
Most helpful negative review
Average Rating:(2.0)out of 5 stars
Dark, gloppy
Much much much darker than expected very heavy on the lid. I was looking for a creamy stick not actual paint on goo. Not fun trying to get it off just a bad idea all around just give me a cream stick please please please please please
High Impact Color
1722 reviews
Average Rating:(5.0)out of 5 stars

My favorite eyeshadow right now

Verified purchase

Love the sparkling peach color! This is my favorite eye shadow right now. It is so easy to apply on the way out the door when I don't have a lot of “mirror time” in the mornings! A few quick swipes and it wears all day long. I originally loved the matte color, but then I got kinda hooked on the sparkling one recently. This is my second purchase of this remarkable product.

Helpful?
Average Rating:(5.0)out of 5 stars

Product quality is as advertised

Verified purchase

This stuff is easy to apply and STAYS ON ALL DAY

Helpful?
Average Rating:(5.0)out of 5 stars

Very impressed

I was hesitant about this eyeshadow because I didn't know what the texture would be like or if it would stay. I love the texture of this! It has a lightweight, mousse texture and stays in place on my eyelids all day which I was pleasantly surprised by. It's also very easy to apply and I found it best to blend out with my finger instead of a brush. [This review was collected as part of a promotion.]

Helpful?
Average Rating:(4.0)out of 5 stars

Shady Violet

When I first got infallible paints eyeshadow, I was iffy about how well it was going to go on and stay. It looks like a lip gloss container, which makes it nice to just stuck in your purse and take it on the go. The first try, I was surprised to see it actually is like paint. You put it on, and wait for it to dry. The color isn't as bold once dry (which I liked.) I got lots of compliments when I wore it! [This review was collected as part of a promotion.]

Helpful?
Average Rating:(4.0)out of 5 stars

Not too bad.

For someone that doesn't wear make up that often, I found the eyeshadow a little intimidating. Also, the cool ivory is a little too metallic. Once you get the hang of how it works, the concept of the eye shadow is pretty cool. It went on smooth and lasted long. [This review was collected as part of a promotion.]

Helpful?
Average Rating:(4.0)out of 5 stars

Lovely long lasting eye color

I loved getting this eye color. I have green eyes so purple makes them stand out which I love. At first I was a little scared that the lighter color was going to be very bright, but once you blend the color into your eyelid it's much more subdued. I found that this liquid eye color was a little easier to get precisely in the crease than a normal eyeshadow with a brush. Overall I really liked the color, and the length of wear it provided. [This review was collected as part of a promotion.]

Helpful?
Average Rating:(3.0)out of 5 stars

Sleek, light, royal color

This eye showdown is perfect for a bold look with a little bit of a softer side. I just put this on to wear, and it was super easy to blend (with my finger) into the lighter shade of purple. Although, you do have to be careful not to rub your finger across your lid or press down too firmly otherwise the color will lift. I find the tones together to be a perfect match and will be wearing this eyeshadow just in time for summer! [This review was collected as part of a promotion.]

Helpful?
Hi there! We are so glad to hear you are loving the bold look these paints provide. To prevent any rub-off, we recommend using our Infallible Pro-Spray and Set Makeup Extending Spray after applying the shadow. This will help to lock the look in. We hope this advice is helpful! Thanks for reaching out to us. We're so glad you did!
Average Rating:(3.0)out of 5 stars

It's definitely noir

I thought that the darkest gray and black would be perfect for me, boy was I wrong. The paints smudged, a lot and I have pale skin, so basically I ended up having to redo my makeup. Finally, I thought I had it right, and then fifteen minutes later I go into the bathroom to see that there is nothing left on my eyebrows. (To be fair, I didn't use a primer.) Finally I decided to use it as a base for powdered eyeshadow. That worked a whole lot better. Overall, maybe my pale friends should try to avoid it, but it wasn't a bad product, just needs some work I think, and maybe there is such a thing as "too much pigment". [This review was collected as part of a promotion.]

Helpful?
Hi Rapunzchelle! Thank you for trying our Infallible Paint Eye Shadow! To prevent the product from smudging, we would recommend using your finger to apply less product. Because this product is highly pigmented, you can use minimal product and still have great color payoff. We would also recommend trying a primer like our De-Crease Eye Shadow primer. This will keep the application process neat and effortless! You can check out our primer by clicking on the link below: http://www.lorealparisusa.com/products/makeup/eye/eye-shadow/de-crease.aspx?shade=Eye-Shadow-Base-Light We hope this helps!
Average Rating:(3.0)out of 5 stars

Not that bad but not so good.

First place, loved the colors, much more vibrant than expected. The formula, well, I didn't like it that much. I never use cream eyeshadows since I find powder eyeshadows more easy to blend and work with. I also have hooded and droopy eyes so they tend to get more messy once applied. I tried this one without an eyeshadow primer, and it didn't stay put more than 2 hours. The colors faded too quick. It wasn't that difficult to blend in my opinion, but the fact that it didn't last much was a bummer. [This review was collected as part of a promotion.]

Helpful?
Hi xyehsx! We are so happy to hear you loved the colors of our Infallible Paints Eye Shadow! We would suggest using an eye shadow primer like our De-Crease Eye Shadow Primer. This will ensure the product lasts longer, and allow the product to glide on more smoothly. You can view this primer by clicking on the link below: http://www.lorealparisusa.com/products/makeup/eye/eye-shadow/de-crease.aspx?shade=Eye-Shadow-Base-Light
Average Rating:(2.0)out of 5 stars

Dark, gloppy

Verified purchase

Much much much darker than expected very heavy on the lid. I was looking for a creamy stick not actual paint on goo. Not fun trying to get it off just a bad idea all around just give me a cream stick please please please please please

Helpful?
Average Rating:(3.0)out of 5 stars

Creamy Shadow

I got the Infallible Paints Eyeshadow in Shady Violet. Overall, I don't think I would purchase this product because I don't think it's the most convenient to use over regular eye shadows. The formula of the shadow is nice and creamy, which I love but when you put it on with the applicator it comes out a bit chunky and can be a bit difficult to work with. The lighter purple is very light once it's spread out on the eye though. The colors can be blended with your finger or a brush but it does dry fast so you have to act quickly when applying to get the look you want. I do like the finish of the shadow as it doesn't look wet but ends up looking like a powder shadow once it's dry. The color didn't wear well throughout the day, unfortunately and ends up looking a bit messy within a few hours even with an eye shadow primer underneath. I know it's just a shadow so smell isn't super important but it does have a plastic smell to me, which I really dislike. I do love that this is a double ended product though with the light purple and dark purple so that you can create a look with just this tube. [This review was collected as part of a promotion.]

Helpful?
Hi Ashley! Thank you for taking the time to try this product. We appreciate your comments and will be sharing them with others on our team. We do suggest using a setting spray, such as our Infallible Pro-Spray and Set Makeup Extending Spray. This will help to lock in the look and keep the paints from smearing throughout the day. We hope this helps! We are so glad you reached out to us!
Average Rating:(5.0)out of 5 stars

Bold, long - wearing eye shadow

I decided to try the eye shadow duo 302 shady violet because it's something out of my comfort zone. The lighter color is a pretty periwinkle color. The darker shade looks like a lighter shade of plum. Together these two cream shadows are suppose to allow you to create a ombre effect. Both shades of eyeshadow come with their own doe foot applicator. This is very considerate because it allows you to precisely apply the shadow where you want to. Both shades are creamy and glide onto your lids very easily. Both formulas take a minute or two to dry which allows you to blend out the shades before they dry. Both cream eyeshadows were very pigmented and opaque so only a little of the product is needed for full coverage. I have to say the periwinkle color is lighter than i thought it would be so I needed to tone it down a little by removing some and then adding a little back onto my lid. The color combination is very pretty and blends well together. While the doe applicators are ideal for putting some of the product on your lid I would recommend using your normal brushes to blend out the colors. I didn't have any problems with the cream shadow crumbling off or creasing even after wearing a full day 7-8 hours. The colors are a bit bolder than I expected them to be so I would recommend them for a party or night event but I was able to make them a bit more daytime friendly by toning down the periwinkle color. Overall I'm pretty impressed with these shadows. They were easy to apply, easy to blend, lasted all day without creasing, crumbling or a need to reapply. I would rate this a 5.0/5.0 for the great formulation of these shadows but a 4.0/5.0 for this bold color combination but the inability to wear during the day unless you tone down how bright the periwinkle is. [This review was collected as part of a promotion.]

Helpful?
Average Rating:(4.0)out of 5 stars

A Different Kind of Eyeshadow

I have to say I wasn't overly excited about this product when I first saw it. I'm a powder eyeshadow fan so I formed opinions of this product before even opening the package, but I thought I would give it a try and see what this liquid eyeshadow duo is all about. First off, I think the package of the product was done nicely. It has a sleek design but nothing to eye catching to really draw me into the product. I think the fact that each color has its own applicator was a great idea, especially since this is a thick, creamy product. The amount you get of each color is also plenty of product. Also, the size of the product is perfect for travel and keeping in your makeup bag. I feel like each end has a good and secure closure so I would not be worried about the product spilling in my makeup bag. Onto the product, I swatched the product on my hand before applying it to my eye lids. I wanted to test some things out first. Both shades of purple had great color payoff with just one swipe of the applicator. The picture attached shows one swipe of each color. I noticed it didn't dry right away, which is great because it gives you some time to work with the product to be able to blend it on your eyes. I blended it on the back of my hand and was able to get a great blend without a lot of smearing. It drys as a matte finish and sets pretty well for a budge proof look. I left the swatch on my hand for a couple of hours and went about my day to see the wear. It didn't easily wash off with soap and water. It needed to be scrubbed off my hand. I even used some make up remover for the darker shade. During the time the swatches were on my hand, I did not have any smudging of the product. The color seemed to last and didn't fade away. After it passed this test, I decided to put a look together on my eyes. First time I applied the product without any eyeshadow primer and just used to the two shades of purple. I found it to be hard to blend the product out with my finger or the applicator. To get a put together look I had to use a separate makeup brush to blend to product enough on my eyes to obtain a look that was wearable for me. I used the darker shade in the crease of my eyelid and the lighter shade on my eye lid. I tested this product for and 8 hour day. I did notice some wear but the end of the day. The color seemed to fade a little bit and I had little areas where the product had wore off. The product came off with a gentle make up remover. Through multiple days I tried the product with eyeshadow primer, I applied liquid black eyeliner and also used with some powder shadow for different kinds of looks. Using the product with the eyeshadow primer made it harder to blend out the creamy product. I finally got the look I wanted but it took some extra work. With the liquid liner, it didn't run into the eyeshadow or mess up the look of the eyeshadow. No problems with that. I also did not have any problems using it with powder eye shadow. It blended right in and I was able to use this cream eyeshadow along with powder shadow. Overall I give this product a 4/5. I think the quality of the product itself is nice and creamy and has great color payoff. The packaging is sleek and compact for easy storage and travel. My areas for improvement would just be for a little change in the formula to be a bit easier to blend with your finger instead of having to use a separate makeup brush. I also think putting two different colors on one eyeshadow duo would give opportunity for more looks that could be created. Having two shades of the same color doesn't give me a bunch of options for different looks. I would recommend this product to a friend and I will be purchasing other colors to create more looks. I am overall satisfied with this product and happy with the results of my makeup looks. [This review was collected as part of a promotion.]

Helpful?
Average Rating:(2.0)out of 5 stars

Not So- Infallible

My experience with this product has not been good. Firstly, I think the color combination was not wisey considered: the mistress noir selection included two colors, black and a grey/silverish metallic. The two colors did not go well together. The black was way to dark and could only be used if your intent is to have gothic look. The grey/silver color was a little too light, it did not pop on the eyes, it looked very bland. The name of the color combo has a sexy vibe (Mistress Noir) and my expectation was that it would provide a smokey eye for going out. However, the product did not live up to that. I understand that these are paints and meant for long wear, however, they were very dry and looked dry when on. There was no dewy look on the eyes, just very dry. This product was also, very difficult to take off, I had to scrub it off. I would not recommend this product and especially not this color combo, it was not a win for me. The picture included, showcases how dry it looks on skin. [This review was collected as part of a promotion.]

Helpful?
Hello ajames27! Thank you for giving the Infallible Paints Eye Shadow - Mistress Noir a try! We appreciate you taking the time to provide us with information about your experience with this product. We consider direct consumer feedback like yours priceless. It helps us improve our products and deliver the best-in-market products we strive for!
Average Rating:(3.0)out of 5 stars

Creamy challenge

I do not wear cream eyeshadow very often. I used to wear them a long time ago but they would often clump or do not stay on well. I found that not too much has changed in the cream eyeshadow. The formula is a better than some of the others. When applying it the colors are super thick and sticky. I used a eye makeup brush to try to blend together the light and dark so it was not a solid color. I found that it kind of worked but didn't not blend well. Maybe a sponge would have worked better? I also tried to add some powder shadow in with the creams to add accent or shadow and it wouldn't sit very well. I couldn't push down a lot or the cream would come up. I was very impressed with the pigment that you could get with the cream. This was very purple. The makeup did not clump as badly as some creams I have used but there was light clumping in the crease of my eyelid. It did come off really easily with eye makeup remover. I wouldn't go out of my way for these but I would maybe include a few colors that could do a really good solid highlight accent. They were the perfect option for my 90s party outfit. [This review was collected as part of a promotion.]

Helpful?
Hi kristin_nicole! Thank you for trying & submitting your feedback on our product - we sincerely appreciate your comments! We are glad you were able to use this duo for your 90s party outfit! - your picture shows a beautiful application of the product and your idea to use powder eye shadows to blend was expertly done. We suggest to check out our Colour Riche Eye shadow in Paris Beach for a highlight on the inner lid & underneath the brow bone - this has gel-powder technology for easy blending & application. You will find more information about this product, and all our current products by visiting our website at www.lorealparisusa.com.
Average Rating:(4.0)out of 5 stars

New & Interesting

First off I noticed that the eye shadow goes on wetish & drys like a regular powder eye shadow. which is cool because I thought it was going to stay wet. It stayed on through out the day which is good. A start off con for me is the applicator, I'd have to practice a lot to use it and get it n right. It's also not the easiest to remove, so if you do may a mistake, you'll need a bit of makeup remover. In turn making it pretty smudge proof which can be a pro once you get you desired look, then a possible con when applying. Overall I like the concept, it's new & different, I'm going to continue to play around with it & see how it goes. [This review was collected as part of a promotion.]

Helpful?
Average Rating:(3.0)out of 5 stars

Great for the right person

This product is amazing for the right person. This product is for people who like very bold eyes. I personally don't really enjoy bold eyes. I have dark skin so the pigment I received was very unflattering. Overall, this product worked exactly how it was supposed to. It went on very smooth and was comfortable. It was also long lasting. I didn't have to reapply at all through out my day. The lighter shade is better if you have darker skin. I would recommend blending it out with your finger like I did. [This review was collected as part of a promotion.]

Helpful?
Hi aliyah_danielle! Thank you for your feedback on our new Infallible Paints Eye Shadow and your helpful advice to others! This product comes in 12 duo shades as well if the color you received is not right for you. You will find more information about this product, and all our current products by visiting our website at www.lorealparisusa.com.
Average Rating:(5.0)out of 5 stars

Loving Infalliable Paints Eyeshadow

I think the Infalliable Paints Eyeshadow was absolutely amazing. I am a lover of makeup 100%, and of course that means I love eyeshadow. I'm used to the regular old powdered eyeshadows, but this is a game changer. It made applying and blending the beautiful cool ivory color so much easier because it's in liquid form! I highly recommend purchasing the Infalliable Paints Eyeshadow from L'ORÉAL if you'd like easier application and a beautiful color that stands out, you will not regret it! [This review was collected as part of a promotion.]

Helpful?
Average Rating:(4.0)out of 5 stars

True to its name

I recently used the Infallible Paints Eyeshadow in the Shady Violet color. It was really neat to put on because it really felt like I was painting my eyelids. I found that the eyeshadow dried pretty quickly. In fact, it dried quicker than I expected, which was great. The colors were not what I would typically gravitate towards (lighter and darker purple), but when I blended them together, I found I really liked it. I thought the wear lasted pretty long as well. All in all, I was impressed with the eyeshadow and would use again. [This review was collected as part of a promotion.]

Helpful?
Average Rating:(3.0)out of 5 stars

Not the best liquid eyeshadow

This eye shadow is okay. I don't know if it's just the color that i have (shady violet) or in general but i find that the lighter color is a bit chalky. I wouldn't mind giving the other colors a chance. though. [This review was collected as part of a promotion.]

Helpful?
Hello! We are sorry to hear that you didn't like the results the Shady Violet gave you. These Paints are available in 11 other shades, so hopefully one of the other shades will work better. We will definitely pass along your comments regarding the chalky look of the lighter shade. We hope you continue using our other products with complete satisfaction. Thanks so much for contacting us!
Electrode, App-reviews-app, Comp-2904f4f4-8608-4139-a4ad-a5ada84d14f8, DC-scus-prod-a4, ENV-prod-a, PROF-PROD, VER-22.4.3, SHA-f7d5d773c4aed1253b9c82c04fa4514d41e2f133, CID-