We decided to try a fabric liner after always using vinyl ones. Our first was from another store, and after hanging and taking a shower, we ended up with our *entire* bathroom floor covered in water. The water went right through the liner, hit the shower curtain and ran down outside the tub and all over the floor. Decided to try the Walmart Essentials brand, which did feel more like plastic (the other brand felt more like a fabric, like bedsheets). Figured that was the problem, and that this would work. However, again, after hanging and taking a shower, the bathroom floor is covered with water! Same thing - the water went right through this liner! What am I missing? I see so many positive reviews for this product, yet for us, it lets water pass right through. Unless we can nail down the issues with these fabric liners, it's back to vinyl for us. Shame, we really like the look and feel of the fabric... (Note: The pic above is *not* this product as the Essentials does not have metal grommets around the holes - at least ours didn't. This pic is used again for the name-brand liner shown elsewhere here.)
Was this review helpful? (0) (0)
Thank you! You have successfully submitted feedback for this review.