Hello, Hello. Sign In
Please enter a valid city, state or zip code
134 reviews | 4.2 out of 5
No more tarantula eyes with this mascara! it glides on no clumping! there is no comparison to anything else out there!
i've been a maybeline mascara fan forever but the great lash waterproof was a bit too drying and i only wore it if i went swimming but i wanted something to wear that would make it through a gym workout after work that didn't dry my lashes out too much so i decided to give this a try. it's awesome, my lashes are soft and fluffy and the mascara stays on through my workout. i'm very happy with this product, leave it to maybeline to have the best mascara at the best prices. to the woman with the melting issue.. if you have an oil based eye cream around your eyes, then yes it's going to run. i use a serum that doesn't contain oil, i have had no running at all.
I don't use a lot of make up, and expect to apply it and forget it's there. I fell in love with this mascara when i first put it on, because i could use one coat and just get a little enhancement, or several for a night out. It was so easy to apply and looked great, every lash coated separately, no clumping, even coat. I was ecstatic at how soft it felt when it dried. I work behind a counter, easy job, and the mascara didn't last through one shift. It was the only thing i had on, and I got home to realize that i looked like i got punched in both eyes, having acquired huge black smudges under the lower lash that, unlike the mascara on my lashes, was actually waterproof. I was crushed at this HUGE flaw in an otherwise great product.
Actually Waterproof!! It still looked great after bathing dogs for 9 hours and being constantly soaked. Also, it stays so soft, not still like other waterproof ones. Hella good mascara.
I am 51 years old and feel like I have tried every mascara out there....the older i get the more my eyelashes thin out and "need help". Every mascara I have used turns my eyelashes brittle and spider like...not to mention when I remove it out comes my lashes as well. This mascara is the ULTIMATE!!! Soft Yes!!!! My eyelashes are soft and not brittle; and when I remove it NO lashes come off with it. I recommend this mascara 100%. It is the BEST I have ever used...and I've been around the block a few times!
I LOVED this mascara and bought it several times, until I could no longer find it in Black/Brown, or Blackish Brown. I don't feel as natural with Jet Black lashes, so I had to switch to another mascara to find the Black/Brown color I wanted.
WHY was this color discontinued??? I can't understand it.
I am on the fence with this mascara. It is not glam but does leave your lashes with a natural look. No clumping, wand takes a lot of getting used to. You don't think it is even going on until you are done. I do like the no smudging and no clumping, but not sure if I will purchase again or not. I guess it is called soft for a reason - ha ha.
Great product. no clumps and the wand is huge, which makes my lashes even longer!
Lashes are not much fuller and does come off during the day.
Still smears some and does flake. Not up to Maybelline standards.
I was excited to purchase and try this mascara. I looked forward to a mascara that was waterproof but would not be brittle on my lashes. Well, this mascara smudges and rubs off under my eyes all day long until I wash it off. I don't even want to wear it anymore. Unless you like looking like a racoon, I recommend you do not purchase this mascara!!! Not worth buying.
I have very sensitive eyes. Also my lashes curl and touch each other constantly. It is exactly what they say. It does not clump and is soft on the eyelashes. It is waterproof and stays on in the water. I only gave a average on the color because I cannot get the brownish black which I like. I wish Walmart would carry it. I do have to say it has been hard to find lately.
I've been using this mascara almost consistently for years. Every time I tried something new I was sorely disappointed and had to go back and buy this product right away. What I love most about this product is that after curling my eyelashes I can apply this mascara and it doesn't make them go straight again. It's also not clumpy. The only small issue I have with it is that it flakes a little bit sometimes after being worn a few hours.
Product is good in that it does stay on, and it's easy to take off when you want too.
Only issue that I noticed is it doesn't add any length to my lashes, and it seems hard to get from root to tip of lashes, almost seems too dry.
I layered it with another mascara. I also noticed that now after having it for a few weeks, it's starting to smell very strongly.
Does not iritate my eyes at all and stays soft like it says, but I was trying this for my wedding day and will not be using it.
I have been using the Stiletto mascara for about 2 years, and was ready for something different. I bought this after reading the reviews, and....LOVE IT!!! I could definitely tell the difference in my lower lashes right away, then applied 2 coats to the upper ones, and it worked great! Very easy to apply! I wore it to church, then shopping afterward and had no problem with smudging or anything. Also removed very easily with a makeup remover cloth! Would highly recommend!!
I've used this mascara since highschool (about 10yrs.) and I love it. It doesn't smear when I get allergies or smudge at the end of the day. It's waterproof while still being extremely soft and natural looking. Absolute best drug store mascara!
This was great! It doesn't sweat off or run. And it still looks clean. Soft to the touch with zero clumping!
I've been using this mascara for about forever and half. Sometimes I try to get creative and buy another mascara with a crazy cool new packaging (usually more expensive) and ALWAYS end up kicking myself in the butt because none ever beat this mascara. DON'T try to fix what isn't broken and this, is definitely the best out there.
This mascara goes on evenly with absolutely no clumps and lasts all day!
I have Asian eyelashes so they are naturally very short and super straight unless curled. To keep that curl I need a waterproof mascara but I hate how some waterproof mascara's make my eyelashes hard and brittle plus taking it off is a horrible experience resulting in lost eyelashes. This mascara is really good! Holds the curl, makes my eyelashes soft not hard, and easy to take off (well, I switch to using olive oil as a makeup remover so no more losing eyelashes anymore!) but even with regular makeup remover, my eyelashes still don't fall off. I really love this mascara and will continue purchasing it. =)