Maybelline is hands down my favorite drugstore brand, but I found this product to be terrible. You get a reasonable amount of product for the price, and the color is accurate, but that wasn't my problem. When I first used it the tip was still sharp and it went on with precision. I did find that it tugged on my lashline in an uncomfortable way. After a day or two it broke. Half of the stick just crumbled. Now, although I dislike it for my lashline, I use it on my lower waterline. Since it's waterproof it does that job perfectly. Overall, in my opinion, this product is below average, but not worthless.