Customer reviews

Customer Reviews | 4 reviews | 3.8 out of 5

4.0 stars

4 reviews | 3.8 out of 5

5 stars
2
4 stars
1
3 stars
0
2 stars
0
1 stars
1
75%
Would recommend to a friend

Age

Gender

BEST Waterproof/Smudgeproof Eyeliner I've found!
9/28/2010

Customer review by 1CosmeticsObsessedGirl

5.0 stars by 1CosmeticsObsessedGirl

Hello "Makeup Sisters", I have used just about every brand and type of waterproof/smudge-proof eyeliner and this is by far the best one. The retractable kind which have, what is *supposed* to be, a self sharpener included never seem to quite sharpen the pencil to the point it was when I purchased it nor any point at all...making it very difficult to make a think exacting line. Also, while trying to sharpen them, the tip often times breaks making for a very irritating experience not to mention going through the pencil in less than a week because it keeps breaking off. The reason I love this product by N.Y.C. is because it always sharpens to a point without breaking. You can use any brand of pencil sharpener and even though the pencil is not wood, but rather a plastic composite of some type...it sharpens beautifully (better than a lot of wood eye pencils. The color is such a beautiful brown that I am also able to use it as a touch-up pencil on my eyebrows. It goes great with my dark haircolor too because since the pencil is not a flat muted brown like a lot of the waterproof kind of pencil colors or too shiny that it looks funny on eyebrows...I was able to get rid of my other eyebrow pencil which was not waterproof and always tended to wear off or smudge. A little goes a long way with this pencil and it truly does not smudge or smear in water or heat. I live in a climate which is often hot and can be humid at times, my previous eyeliners ALWAYS smeared in the heat or would get on the top of my eyelid (u know what I mean?!) I can even take a shower and it will not come off unless I purposely wash it off. Just thought I would spare some of you the money I have wasted on inferior products. I also love that I don't have to go spend 15..20-30+ bucks @ a Mall *Dept Store* to get a good product (note the ingredients on all the makeups when someone tries to tell you that *those brands* are better bcuz they use better ingredients...speaking from someone who used to spend hundreds and hundreds of dollars at those *counters* ;-))!!! OBTW...GREAT for sensitive eyes as well!!! I have really bad seasonal allergies and my eyes often water and itch a lot...and, yes, AGAIN, this product STILL does not smudge or come off into my eyes. Even though is stays on so well it can also be touched up with a damp q-tip also (for example: if you make the line too thick, etc...) Sorry for the LONG run on sentences ;-) I am writing in a hurry and I tend to write like I talk when I am in a rush...LOL!!! Happy shopping and enjoy!!! Sincerely, Makeup Obsessed

Was this review helpful? (40) (1)
Thank you! You have successfully submitted feedback for this review.
1CosmeticsObsessedGirl
South Orange County, CA
Would recommend to a friend? Yes
Age:25 - 34
Ownership:5 - 6 months
Gender:Female
Usage:Every day
Best Eyeliner!! Lasts all day!
10/1/2014

Customer review by fell0wsh0pper

5.0 stars by fell0wsh0pper

This is my every-day eyeliner and I absolutely love it! It doesn't smear or smudge, stays all day, and really brings out my eyes. I've tried a lot of other colors and brands, but this is by far the best for a natural look.

Was this review helpful? (2) (0)
Thank you! You have successfully submitted feedback for this review.
fell0wsh0pper
Would recommend to a friend? Yes
Verified purchaser
Verified purchaser
Customer has been confirmed to have purchased the item from Walmart.
Luckily it was cheap
8/4/2014

Customer review by Satchelicious

1.0 stars by Satchelicious

Based on all the positive reviews, I decided to give this eyeliner pencil a try. Luckily, I didn't spend a fortune because within hours, I had raccoon eyes. Eyeliner did NOT stay put despite using an eyeshadow/eyeliner primer base and then topping the liner off with powder to set it. VERY disappointed! I wanted this product to live up to the reviews, but sadly, it didn't.

Was this review helpful? (2) (0)
Thank you! You have successfully submitted feedback for this review.
Satchelicious
Would recommend to a friend? No
Verified purchaser
Verified purchaser
Customer has been confirmed to have purchased the item from Walmart.
Okay
6/29/2014

Customer review by 8251

4.0 stars by 8251

It smears some from sweating, but okay

Was this review helpful? (2) (1)
Thank you! You have successfully submitted feedback for this review.
8251
hedgesville, wv
Would recommend to a friend? Yes
Age:55 - 64
Gender:Female
Verified purchaser
Verified purchaser
Customer has been confirmed to have purchased the item from Walmart.