Customer reviews

Customer Reviews | 65 reviews | 4.4 out of 5

4.5 stars

65 reviews | 4.4 out of 5

4.5 stars

65 reviews | 4.4 out of 5

Would recommend to a friend
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 stars
1-20 of 61 total reviews
Would recommend to a friend



1-20 of 61 total reviews
1-20 of 61 reviews
Love, love, love this mascara.

Customer review by Danielle79

5.0 stars 11/5/2016 by Danielle79
by Danielle79

I've been using this mascara for 10 years and I have not found anything better! It makes my lashes look so thick! I hope they don't take it off the shelves I've been seeing less and less of it!

Would recommend to a friend? Yes
Skin type:Normal
Great mascara for beginners

Customer review by ayejay21

5.0 stars 7/10/2016 by ayejay21
by ayejay21

This was the very first mascara I ever used when I was 17. Everyone thought I was wearing fake lashes! :)

Baltimore, MD
Would recommend to a friend? Yes
Skin type:Combination
Best Mascara EVER!!

Customer review by SensitiveinArlington

5.0 stars 5/24/2016 by SensitiveinArlington
by SensitiveinArlington

I am allergic to every mascara, except this one!! It holds curl, gives volume and lasts. Better than any high end mascara. Please don't discontinue!!!

Would recommend to a friend? Yes
Skin type:Dry
My favorite mascara

Customer review by JillP

5.0 stars 4/13/2016 by JillP
by JillP

After trying out many mascaras throughout the years I revisited this one. Great bold lashes and lasts all day, great price.

Would recommend to a friend? Yes
Skin type:Normal
Best mascara I've tried, and I've tried many!

Customer review by Chante39

5.0 stars 9/24/2015 by Chante39
by Chante39

LOVE this mascara. It is my new favorite. It does not clump, and makes your lashes look full and curl up. I also love the wand it's the perfect size.

Wichita, Kansas
Would recommend to a friend? Yes
Gives false lash effect

Customer review by BBRoberts

4.0 stars 11/5/2013 by BBRoberts
by BBRoberts

I bought this on a whim from a dollar store once and was very impressed. I normally don't use this brand mascara so when I used it the first time I was like, "WOW" and the best part was it didn't take like a million coats like most mascaras I've used

Would recommend to a friend? Yes
well, it was pretty good...

Customer review by dancer341

3.0 stars 8/24/2011 by dancer341
by dancer341

this was an okay mascara. it clumped up my lashes and didnt volumize so much, the formula was thick and kind of chunked its way on. i used it once, removed it almost right away and stashed it somewhere, i may give it another try, but not anytime soon

New York, NY
Would recommend to a friend? No
The best!!!

Customer review by tracyjhi

5.0 stars 12/15/2007 by tracyjhi
by tracyjhi

I have been using this mascara for years. No smudges ever. I am amazed at the amount of people that I have never met that walk up to me and compliment my eyelashes and ask me what kind of mascara I use. I LOVE this product. It is my beauty secret!!!!

Fairmont WV
Would recommend to a friend? Yes
Make new friends but keep the old...

Customer review by kateS

4.0 stars 10/14/2011 by kateS
by kateS

I love this product but some people have problems with clumping. If you use this product by brushing the back of lashes first then upward, they will not clump. They will look thick/dramatic and clumpfree. Let dry then curl. love this product! G.Luck!

State College, PA
Would recommend to a friend? Yes
Best Mascara Ever

Customer review by Delfino

5.0 stars 4/18/2012 by Delfino
by Delfino

I used Max Factor 2000 Calorie Mascara for years. They stopped selling in the USA. I tried many other mascaras and nothing compared. I was told by Cover Girl on line Chat that if I liked the 2000 calorie I would love this one.......they were right!

Allentown, PA
Would recommend to a friend? Yes
Best Mascara Ever!

Customer review by MakeupsBiggestFan

5.0 stars 11/20/2011 by MakeupsBiggestFan
by MakeupsBiggestFan

I have been using this mascara since I've been sixteen years old. (I am in my late 30s). I can not find one that compares. I went to a MAC cosmetic store and the makeup artist asked what mascara I used. I told them Super Thick. Never discontinue!

South Jersey
Would recommend to a friend? Yes
Way more bang for your buck

Customer review by zoxyroxy

5.0 stars 6/3/2014 by zoxyroxy
by zoxyroxy

I'm always looking for a mascara that is going to give me some extra length but mainly looking for one that will give me fullness. This one here, gives me the fullness I'm looking for in my daily look. I put on 2 coats and it looks awesome!

Would recommend to a friend? Yes
No volume

Customer review by kaos

3.0 stars 9/16/2009 by kaos
by kaos

this would be the perfect mascara if i wasnt looking for volume! it didnt clump added color and the slightest of slight amount of length which would have been perfect with volume! a good mascara but i didnt get any volume from this product!

Would recommend to a friend? Yes
Good for daytime...

Customer review by aalc512

3.0 stars 8/26/2008 by aalc512
by aalc512

This is the first mascara I've ever bought besides clear. I got it at a local discount store for 2 bucks. I got the brown black and it works okay for everyday use. It was somewhat clumpy but I was able to comb them out with my lash comb.

Would recommend to a friend? Yes
one of the best drugstore mascaras

Customer review by CrysLd

4.0 stars 12/14/2011 by CrysLd
by CrysLd

I bought this on a whim, knowing I desperately needed a new mascara & since I was pregnant & the MAC mascara was too expensive at the time, I decided to get this & to my delight, it works very well for the price.. almost as good as MAC.

Pittsburgh, PA
Would recommend to a friend? Yes
An Ohkay Mascara

Customer review by SHS2013

3.0 stars 10/3/2011 by SHS2013
by SHS2013

I really liked this mascara, it made my lashes thick and gave them great length. The issue was, it's too natural for me.. I have this issue with every covergrirl product, I want a more dramatic look for my lashes.... What kind do I use?

Would recommend to a friend? Yes
Last 3 new tubes have seemed old

Customer review by Ocean01

4.0 stars 3/7/2011 by Ocean01
by Ocean01

Been noticing that the last 2 or 3 tubes I've purchased seem to be old. There barely seems to be any mascara in the tube from the get go. Wondering if they are discontinuing this mascara and the stores are getting old supplies?

Girard, OH
Would recommend to a friend? Yes
Love it!!!

Customer review by hhbrmb

5.0 stars 9/14/2010 by hhbrmb
by hhbrmb

I love this mascara. It takes me half the amount of time to put it on than others - no clumps to fix! I have long eyelashes which can be difficult to manage. This mascara defines and separates perfectly! Love the brush!

Maryville, IL
Would recommend to a friend? Yes
THE BEST non-waterproof Mascara on the Market!

Customer review by ShihTzuLuv

5.0 stars 6/9/2014 by ShihTzuLuv
by ShihTzuLuv

The best mascara on the market for the non-waterproof needs. Even though it is non-waterproof...It can surprisingly hold up through a little rain drizzle!

Toronto, ON, Canada
Would recommend to a friend? Yes
Age:35 - 44
The. Best. Ever.

Customer review by szivigrrl

5.0 stars 10/10/2007 by szivigrrl
by szivigrrl

This mascara is the gold standard, the mascara that all others I've tried are judged against. Makeupwise, there has never been a remark other women have made to me more than, "Oh my God! What mascara do you use?"

Augusta, GA
Would recommend to a friend? Yes
1-20 of 61 total reviews
1-20 of 61 reviews