Hello, Hello. Sign In
Please enter a valid city, state or zip code
54 reviews | 3.1 out of 5
This pie is delicious! I can't even explain it. I use to always buy the Edwards brand, which is still good, but I just love that this tastes so close to a real homemade key lime pie from key west!
Marie's pies are all great. This Key Lime pie just needs to be thawed. It is delicious with just enough Key lime tartness, the wonderful flakey crust of all Marie's pies. I recommend this pie to all my friends and no one has ever been disappointed.
THis pie is soo good. Didin't have time to bake so I brought this to a family dinner. Everyone LOVED it.
Wow, fresh and simply divine key lime flavor!! I give it 10 stars the pie exceed the scale. I sum this pie up in one word Wonderful!
I wanr to say NO to recommending this KLP because it's so good once others taste it ,it may never be any in the store for me to purchase it just that GOOD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Tried Key Lime pie for the first time and I'm hooked. Delicious, mildly tart filling with firm consistency and crunchy graham crust. After discovering my new found love of Key Lime Pie I tried the other frozen brand pie and it was nowhere near this quality. Try to keep the uneaten pie in the coldest part of your fridge because the filling needs to stay extra cold to keep its consistency. I'm buying a pie a week. Thanks, Marie.
I thought this key lime pie was amazing. It's not too tart, perfectly sweet, and is smooth and silky. For a frozen pie, it tasted very fresh after I defrosted it. Everyone's taste buds are different, mine really enjoyed this pie. I'm dreaming of having another slice right now...
If I were offered a last meal, I would ask for the Marie Callenders Key Lime Pie and leave this world a Happy Man and satisfied. My only hope is I would go to Key Lime Pie Nirvana and eat Marie Callenders' Key Lime Pies for ALL Eternity! I cannot get tired of this dessert! My local grocer stopped stocking them for some reason but I've been on them about re-ordering. I tell all my friends about it. This is my favorite dessert...PERIOD!
MMmmm....Key Lime Pie. Either fresh or frozen, it is soooo hard to find. . . and this is Amish country. Marie Callender's the best key lime available. I've searched many places far and wide. This stands tall above the rest! It's the kinda of thing you have to open up in the car "while still frozen," break off a piece, and eat before you get home. . . "Oh, And please use the stoplights well, don't break it off while the car is in motion." Safety...uh pie..no, safety..no, pie....no, Safety First!!!
Creamy, limy, made my mouth happy. Delightfully refreshing. I wasn't expecting it to be that good. Give me another!
Best pie ever. If you like food, you will love this pie.
My husband and I are key lime pie fanatics and this pie rates up there with the best I've tasted.
My mom bought one of these a few years ago and I could not believe how close to a real key west key lime pie it came. It's my favorite frozen/store bought key lime pie! I always buy it for holidays and birthdays!
Tried many key lime pies and this one is hands down...THE BEST. Most desserts taste better when I make them myself. Thank you for a pie that gives me a break.
This is by far the best Key Lime Pie available anywhere other than the Florida Keys. It has the authentic taste of a freshly made pie.
Everyone at My House Loved this Pie !!!! It was Awesome !!!!!!
I've had "the" key lime pie in Key West, FL and this pie is as yummy as real thing! It's amazing!
One of the best Key Lime Pies I've had in a long time. I had it at a church potluck and it was very tasty. I thought it was homemade until I saw the box. :)
BUY BUY BUY!! This tastes so good!! I can't even....
IT is so good!!!!!!!!!!! am must have in my freezer!!!