These are super healthy treats and I feel good giving them to my pups 2 or 3 times a day when they potty. I gave it 4 stars because of the odd almost licorice like odor, which puts off my Golden Retriever. The Lab and Dutch love them. We switched to ALL Milos Kitchen Treats and like the Apple Sausage best, the Meatballs concern me with choking hazard as they are ping pong sized meatballs which my dogs wolf down! Order three or more bags at Walmart online and they ship free to your door, why not?! They break in half easy if you want to ration your dog's intake and stretch your dollar, it's still a goodly sized portion.