First let me say, this doesn't resemble cottage cheese at all!! Nothing made to be healthier is ever going to have the same consistency as regular full fat, sugar laden ice cream. The consistency of this is smooth not lumpy and all flavors I've tasted have great taste- mint chip, red velvet, chocolate , chocolate chip cookie dough, vanilla bean, lemon cake, strawberry, sea salt caramel, cookies & cream, s'mores, and pistachio. The ice cream is best if you let it sit out and melt a little, just my opinion!!