I really loved the shades of color with the shimmer. It's perfect for what I was wanting. There is a need to tap it off a bit after you get some out of the palette, as it tends to be very loose and get in your eyes or on your cheeks as you apply. But overall I'm happy. It did come with the far left shade broken, but I kept it as there are so many to choose from. I would buy it again, but wish it wasn't so loose and a bit more creamy and smooth.