I am reviewing the Flower Line product, On Your Mark Eye Liner. I've been using this eyeliner for several days now. It is the color Black, which can appear harsh if applied too thick. I apply a thin line most days. But I've been playing around with it, for more of a dramatic look. I can make it much thicker if I want. It comes compact so I can carry it in my purse if I need to. The liquid is concealed inside the pen with a small eyeliner brush on the other end. The brush is hidden by a top. No danger of the liner leaking or getting in your purse when properly fitted by the top. I'm not a huge fan of liquid eyeliners. More of a eyeliner pencil girl. I plan on purchasing the Flowers eyeliner pencil, called Easy on the Eyes. I have found by using an eyeliner pencil first, then using the liquid eyeliner, I am more in control of how I want it to look. This eyeliner is smudge-proof and will last all day. It does seem to lighten as the day goes on. It's not as black as when I first apply it. It washes off with soap and water. It is available in Black and Brown. Made in the USA. Drew Barrymore Flower Line Product. Very affordable and sold by our local Walmart Stores. I recommend trying the Flower Line Products. I will be checking my local Walmart for more of the available products.