I just love it, one of my cousins introduced me to this eyeliner and I've been using it ever since. I always got complements all the time on my eye makeup. I love it cause I can always get that fine thin curved angle line at the end with this eyeliner which everyone always complements me on and ask how I can make that fine line. I would have gave this product a 5 stars but a few people I know who gave it a try would have trouble of the eyeliner cracking and start wearing out. I never had trouble with it. The only trouble I had was one of the bottles I bought would leak when I pulled out the sick/brush and around the stick the eyeliner would dry there but I guess it was a bad container.