This is the only liner I use. I absolutely love it. I'm surprised by all the bad reviews... but I think personal tastes are more relevant here than the quality of the product. Yes, its oily and thus smudges; but the deep, matte \"ebony black\" color it produces can't be beat! No other eyeliner does that (not that I know of anyway). I love the smudged smokey look, so if that's what you're looking for, this is PERFECT.
Color is brighter than expected and the lip liner is dry making it difficult to apply. I didn't read the product description well enough and didn't realize this is a wooden pencil that needs sharpening. I would have made a different decision if I had realized that.
Very happy that Walmart is stocking this make-up essential. Have tried far more expensive brands, but always come back. Since I have been using this product for years and am so satisfied, I purchased 12!
This eyeliner is not for me. Unfortunately this is the only eyeliner I own at the moment, so instead of wasting this product I use it for my waterline. I tried to make a nice cat eye on my lash line area but it just smudged like crazy and it is hard to \"define the line.\" I see where Maybelline was trying to go with this but I personally don't like it. I gave it three stars because I can at least still use it in a way.