Refine
to
Sort

Maybelline New York Color Sensational Lipcolor, Deepest Cherry, 0.15 oz

$5.50
$36.67 / oz
4.5 stars (61) ratings
  • Crisper color from pure pigments
  • Creamier feel from nourishing honey nectar
  • Lush, tempting shades
    • Free shipping on orders over $50

    Maybelline New York Color Elixir by Color Sensational Lip Color, 0.17 fl oz

    $6.94
    Rollback
    3.5 stars (21) ratings
  • Rich, saturated color
  • Smoothing angora brush delivers a polished, even application
  • Balm-infused formula
    • Free shipping on orders over $50
    • Free store pickup today

    NYC New York Color Big Bold Plumping Lip Gloss, Big is Beautiful

    $3.57
    3.5 stars (3) ratings
  • Fuller, sexier, shinier lips are yours in a single stroke
  • Dimethicone to provide smooth, silky application
    • Free shipping on orders over $50

    NYC New York Color Expert Last Satin Matte Lip Color, 0.11 fl oz

    $1.87
    4.0 stars (4) ratings
  • Improved moisturizing, long-wearing formula
  • Wears up to 6 hours
  • Amplified color
    • Free shipping on orders over $50

    NYC New York Color Smooch Proof Liquid Lip Stain, 7ml

    $2.77
  • Easy application of intense colors that last up to 4 hours
  • Non-sticky gloss that does not fade
    • Free shipping on orders over $50

    N.Y.C. New York Color City Proof Twistable Intense Lip Primer, Universal, 0.07 fl oz

    $2.77
    $39.57 / fl oz
    5.0 stars (1) ratings
  • Preps and primes lips
  • Makes lips feel smoother
  • Helps to visually reduce lines and ridges
    • Free shipping on orders over $50

    NYC New York Color 8HR City Proof Extended Wear Lip Gloss, Freeze Mauve, .22 fl oz

    $2.77
    $12.59 / fl oz
  • Wears up to 8 hours
  • Full coverage in one stroke
  • High intensity color and shine
    • Free shipping on orders over $50

    Maybelline New York Color Sensational Lipcolor, Mauve Mania, 0.15 oz

    $5.50
    $36.67 / oz
    4.5 stars (59) ratings
  • Crisper color from pure pigments
  • Creamier feel from nourishing honey nectar
  • Lush, tempting shades
    • Free shipping on orders over $50
    • Free store pickup today

    New York Color Up to 8HR City Proof Lip Gloss, Coffee Break

    $2.77 - $2.88
    3.5 stars (6) ratings
  • Heavy dose of color coverage and super shine
  • Lasts up to 8 hours
  • Kokum butter
    • Free shipping on orders over $50

    NYC New York Color Big Bold Plumping Lip Gloss, Big City Blush

    $3.57
    3.0 stars (2) ratings
  • Fuller, sexier, shinier lips are yours in a single stroke
  • Dimethicone to provide smooth, silky application
    • Free shipping on orders over $50

    NYC New York Color Big Bold Plumping Lip Gloss, Pleasantly Plump Pink

    $3.57
  • Fuller, sexier, shinier lips are yours in a single stroke
  • Dimethicone to provide smooth, silky application
    • Free shipping on orders over $50

    NYC New York Color Big Bold Plumping Lip Gloss, Magnified Mauve

    $3.57
  • Fuller, sexier, shinier lips are yours in a single stroke
  • Dimethicone to provide smooth, silky application
    • Free shipping on orders over $50

    NYC New York Color Big Bold Plumping Lip Gloss, Coral to the Max

    $3.57
  • Fuller, sexier, shinier lips are yours in a single stroke
  • Dimethicone to provide smooth, silky application
    • Free shipping on orders over $50

    NYC New York Color Expert Last Lip Lacquer, Riverside Romance, 0.15 fl oz

    $3.57
    $23.80 / fl oz
  • Intense color of a lipstick with the shine of a gloss
  • Rich formula glides on smooth
  • Lips stay hydrated, soft, supple
    • Free shipping on orders over $50

    NYC New York Color Big Bold Plumping Lip Gloss, Full on Fuchsia

    $3.57
  • Fuller, sexier, shinier lips are yours in a single stroke
  • Dimethicone to provide smooth, silky application
    • Free shipping on orders over $50

    NYC New York City Proof Intense Lip Color, Persistent Pink, 0.1 fl oz

    $4.47
    $44.70 / fl oz
    3.5 stars (5) ratings
  • Natural flush of color
  • Buildable coverage when layered to your desires
  • Water-based formula
    • Free shipping on orders over $50

    NYC New York Color 8HR City Proof Extended Wear Lip Gloss, Ruby Pink, 0.22 fl oz

    $2.77
    $12.59 / fl oz
  • Wears up to 8 hours
  • Full coverage in one stroke
  • High intensity color and shine
    • Free shipping on orders over $50

    NYC New York Color Expert Last Lip Lacquer, Chelsea Cherry Blossoms, 0.15 fl oz

    $3.57
    $23.80 / fl oz
  • Intense color of a lipstick with the shine of a gloss
  • Rich formula glides on smooth
  • Lips stay hydrated, soft, supple
    • Free shipping on orders over $50

    NYC New York Color Expert Last Lip Lacquer, Turtle Bay Toffee, 0.15 fl oz

    $3.57
    $23.80 / fl oz
  • Intense color of a lipstick with the shine of a gloss
  • Rich formula glides on smooth
  • Lips stay hydrated, soft, supple
    • Free shipping on orders over $50

    NYC New York Color City Duet 2-in-1 Lip Color

    $2.74
    Out of stock online
    4.5 stars (2) ratings
  • 2 gorgeous shades in 1 single bullet
  • Customize your own shade
  • Available in 10 shades
  • Showing 20 of 13,635 results

    Product Recommendations

    Your recently viewed items

    Clear this list