NYC New York Color Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil, 935A Moody Blue, 0.036 oz

$84.75 / oz
Was: $3.57
  Save $0.18
FREE shipping on orders $50 +
If your order totals $50 or more and you select Value shipping, this item and any other qualifying items ship for free!
Loading options...
Sold by

FREE shipping available

 on $50+ orders


Data unavailable
Data unavailable
Data unavailable
Data unavailable

Pickup not available



Want to pick up your package for free?
Walmart offers free pickup for most orders placed online - for many items as soon as today! Tell us where you are and we'll show you which Walmart stores and partner locations near you are available for package pickup.
  • Waterproof formula
  • Long-lasting coverage
  • Dermatologist tested
  • About this item

    Important Made in USA Origin Disclaimer: For certain items sold by Walmart on, the displayed country of origin information may not be accurate or consistent with manufacturer information. For updated, accurate country of origin data, it is recommended that you rely on product packaging or manufacturer information.

    About this item

    Important Made in USA Origin Disclaimer: For certain items sold by Walmart on, the displayed country of origin information may not be accurate or consistent with manufacturer information. For updated, accurate country of origin data, it is recommended that you rely on product packaging or manufacturer information.

    NYC New York Color Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil:

    • Waterproof formula
    • Long-lasting coverage
    • Dermatologist tested


    Instructions: If tip dries out, resharpen.


    Color: Blue
    Gender: Women
    Recommended Use: Pencil
    Manufacturer: Generic
    Features: Waterproof ,  Eyeliner pencil ,  Moody blue ,  Nyc ,  Smudgeproof
    Count: 1
    Size: .036 oz
    Is Travel Size: Y
    Model: 935A
    Is Waterproof: Y
    Brand: NYC
    Assembled Product Dimensions (L x W x H): 0.38 x 0.38 x 5.38 IN

    Customer Reviews

    Customer Reviews | 1938 reviews | 4.5 out of 5

    4.5 stars

    1938 reviews | 4.5 out of 5

    4.5 stars

    1938 reviews | 4.5 out of 5

    Would recommend to a friend
    5 stars
    4 stars
    3 stars
    2 stars
    1 stars
    1-5 of 1938 total reviews
    Would recommend to a friend



    I LOVE the City Proof 24HR Waterproof Eyeliner fro

    Customer review by 118bri

    5.0 stars 2/4/2016 by 118bri
    by 118bri

    I used to wear pencil eyeliner everyday. I loved the ease of application of a pencil eyeliner to my waterline vs liquid eyeliner, but I had to stop because I would end up with raccoon eyes at the end of the day. No matter what I used. So when I received this to try, it was a little exciting (because I miss pencil eyeliner) but I just knew I'd end up annoyed when I had to constantly rub under my eyes all day. To my surprise, this eyeliner stayed on perfectly all day and did not smudge or "sweat" off. I do have to sharpen it a lot because when I apply it, it just gets used really quickly which is different from other pencils I have used but I think the results are worth it. My pencil was a dark brown (I wear black eyeliner) but it is so dark I loved it! I would 10/10 recommend and I will definitely be buying more (I mean look how cheap this pencil is! I might buy 5!) Love Love Love this product!!!! *I received this eyeliner free to test and review from but my opinions are all my own.

    Would recommend to a friend? Yes
    Highly Pigmented/ Long Wear

    Customer review by Heather56

    4.0 stars 1/16/2016 by Heather56
    by Heather56

    I have bundles of liners, especially black. I am always on the lookout for a Great Liner which is Highly pigments, goes on smooth and lasts all day! This one Is all that! I really do love this liner. The price is fantastic. Plus it is a full size pencil (requires sharpening upon use) which I like because you get more product then the twist ups and can control the point more. I used this product on my upper lid lash line, below my lower lashline and on the waterline. It was awesome! Even after a 14 hour day it was still on even my waterline! That never happens. The only thing Negative I have to say unfortunately is that throughout the day My first day wearing this my eyes burned really bad. I can no longer wear this on my waterline. But it does not irritate my eyes on my skin just the waterline. I might try it on my waterline again to see if it was a fluke! I received this product for review purposes from influenster. This review is original and honest based on my usage of this product since I have received it.

    Pickerington, OH, United States
    Would recommend to a friend? Yes
    Good eyeliner, but very difficult to remove

    Customer review by Mamasita821

    4.0 stars 1/29/2016 by Mamasita821
    by Mamasita821

    I received the NYC City Proof 24HR Waterproof Eyeliner in black complimentary from Influenster for the purpose of my review. All opinions are honest and my own. I was excited when I received this eyeliner, and at first it was better than expected. I liked that the eyeliner went on smoothly, the color was rich, and it really made my eyes pop! What I didn't like is that the pencil's tip went dull pretty quickly, and like other reviewers already stated before me, there is no way to sharpen it. The color itself lasts pretty long, but it still left smudges after a few hours. The worst part was that it was extremely difficult to remove, even with eye make-up remover especially designed to remove waterproof eye make-up. I tried removing it with face wash, even bar soap, and a baby wipe, very frustrating. This is just not something I want to have to deal with after a long day, or a night out. Overall, good product, but could be better!

    California, United States
    Would recommend to a friend? Yes
    Love the color, easy to apply, just doesn't last!

    Customer review by partangel

    4.0 stars 1/17/2016 by partangel
    by partangel

    I typically only wear black eyeliner, but since I started using this eyeliner in a brown color, I have really come to like it. I like the look it gives my eyes. My eyes are hazel and the brown color really makes them pop. This eyeliner goes on pretty easily. I like that it is soft and you don't need to melt it to use it. It just doesn't last as long as I wished it did. I usually have to reapply about halfway through the day. The first time I used it, I removed the cap and stuck it on the bottom of the eyeliner, like I do all my eyeliners, but this one got stuck and wouldn't come off. We actually had to heat it up in order to remove the cap again, and now it just isn't the same. Overall, I would recommend this as an everyday wear eyeliner. It is easy to use and looks great, just plan on reapplying it a few times a day. I received a free sample for testing purposes, my reviw reflects my personal experience with the product.

    Michigan, United States
    Would recommend to a friend? Yes
    Gorgeous and thick!

    Customer review by Neko

    4.0 stars 1/11/2016 by Neko
    by Neko

    I love this eyeliner! I received it for free to try from Influenster, but all opinions are my own. Black eyeliner is my favorite, the one item of makeup i NEVER leave the house without. The only makeup item I have to continually restock on a regular basis because I use it so much. I love NYC products and have used them before, including their liquid eyeliner - gorgeous also! This is smooth and goes on thick and dark, which I love. The only reason I am giving 4 stars is because I am someone who wear contacts and constantly am rubbing at my eyes and blinking. The other NYC waterproof stuff I work holds really well, but this one still started smudging and giving me raccoon eyes after a few hours of wear. I recommend a makeup face spray over your look to keep it in place better, but aside from that (which, again, would have a lot to do with the fact that I am someone rubbing my eyes constantly), the rest of the liner held really well, and I did, in fact, have to scrub a bit to even get it off! But yeah, I love it, and I would even buy it again ^_^b

    Belcamp, MD, United States
    Would recommend to a friend? Yes
    1-5 of 1938 total reviews See all
    1-5 of 1938 reviews

    Customer Reviews | 1938 reviews | 4.5 out of 5

    Customer Reviews

    Customer Q&A

    Questions & Answers 0 questions

    Ask a question

    If you would like to share feedback with us about pricing, delivery or other customer service issues, please contact customer service directly.

    Q&A tips and guidelines

    Q&A Exchange Guidelines

    When writing your question or answer, please follow these guidelines:

    • Do: Make sure your question is directly related to the product
    • Do: Be specific and provide as many details as possible
    • Do: Include the model number (if applicable)
    • Do: Write your question in English
    • Do Not: Include personal information (such as your full name)
    • All submitted questions and answers are subject to the terms set forth in our Terms and Conditions

    We reserve the right not to post your question or answer if it contains any of the following:

    • Any information not related to the actual merchandise or topic
    • Obscenities, discriminatory language or other language not suitable for a public forum
    • Advertisements or “spam” content
    • Email addresses, physical addresses or other forms of contact information
    • Critical or spiteful comments on other questions or answers posted on the page or their authors
    • Any imagery that demonstrates incorrect use of the merchandise
    • Anything that Walmart deems to be inappropriate, at Walmart's discretion

    Provide as many details as possible, including the model number (if applicable).

    Remember: Don’t include personal information (such as your full name).

    Preview Question

    Walmart does not sponsor, recommend or endorse any third party product or service, or any customer ideas or advice.

    Thank you.

    Questions will be checked against our question guidelines and posted within five to seven business days.

    Customers also viewed these products

    Policies & Plans

    See any care plans, options and policies that may be associated with this product.

    Warranty Plan

    Walmart Product Care Plans
    A limited product warranty is included free for most items. With an optional Walmart Care Plan you can enhance the manufacturer's coverage from the date of purchase. Walmart Product Care Plans cover 100% of the cost for repair or replacement, including shipping charges for the exchange.

    We'll show you Care Plan options and pricing at checkout if applicable, or go to for more information.

    Product warranty:  

    See details

    Warranty Information: 

    Did you buy this in a Walmart store?  Get a warranty for it here.

    Gifting plans

    Gift options are not available for this item.

    Pricing policy

    About our prices
    We’re committed to providing low prices every day, on everything. So if you find a current lower price from an online retailer on an identical, in-stock product, tell us and we’ll match it. See more details at Online Price Match.


    Returns are easy at Walmart
    Not happy with a purchase? No problem. We've made returning items as easy as possible. And, most purchases can be returned for free. Learn more about our Returns Policy.