Rated 4.6 out of 5★áby 7reviewers.
Rated 5 out of 5★áby gwennetta I extremely enjoy using this product. It is always sold out or minimally avaliable at my local walmart. I'm going to start ordering this product online since it's so hard to find. It's an easy use item. I love a basic, smooth flowing, dark pencil. I've never liked those automatic or liquid eyeliners and I get comments on my eyes, positive ones, daily! I work with the public. Why change what works? 07/12/2011
Rated 5 out of 5★áby imperfectpicture BEST DRUG STORE EYELINER! I love this eyeliner! It's so smooth, and doesn't wear off like the others. The only color eyeliner I buy is black, most eyeliners aren't smooth and aren't true to their color! Most blacks turn out brown and that is NOT what I want. I have tried many MANY eyeliners and this is by far my favorite. It has lasted me a long time, it's down to a nub. Now I need a new one I can't find it anywhere! I came across it accidentally at a Rite Aid and now it's no where to be found! Going to Walmart tomorrow though now that I've possibly found it again. <3 08/01/2011
Rated 4 out of 5★áby makeupcritic Great Waterproof eyeliner NYC waterproof eyeliner provides an excellent variety of colors in its vibrate quality. I highly recommend this product, for great definition to both upper and lower eyelash. It maybe smudge to give that great smokey eye look. The only downfall to this product is the quatity. The tip end of the product is all you get, so this product doesnt last very long before you have to end up buying another one, but if your a makeup freak like me, its well-worth it!I recommend using the mink brown color tone, its exact to color, than most other brown eyeliner which usually end up looking black anyway. But this provides an excellent brown tones as well. 02/25/2012
Rated 5 out of 5★áby Poptart07 Amazing!!! This is wonderful! I have been using the Covergirl brow shaper and eyeliner pencil, and in comparison, the NYC eyeliner is smoother, more pigmented, and you dont have to PUSH on your eye..... with the Covergirl one, when I would do my waterline i felt like i was about to stab my eyeball..... 04/13/2014
Rated 3 out of 5★áby biscuitslittle Great eyeliner, waterproof after a while. this goes on really smooth and creamy at first, making it an easy application without having to press hard for color. I purchased it because it was waterproof, which it is, but not immediately after application. it doesnt smudge about an hour after application. You must wait for that. 05/14/2014
Rated 5 out of 5★áby makeuploverr worth the price!! I used to use mac eye pencil because I thought I couldn't find a better one but this one is more pigmented and last all day. I really love it and for this price you can't get a better one. I be buying more of it 08/03/2014
Rated 5 out of 5★áby nickiminajfan123 amazing for school!!!!! im active, i go out alot, and im always doing something. so yes waterproof was a must. this eyeliner is so amazing!!!! its super creamy and glides on without a problem. the only fault is how hard it is to sharpen. some of the liner is stuck in the sharpener. but its easy to fix. all and all i love it!!!! 05/18/2014