Rated 3.6 out of 5 by 30
Rated 5 out of 5 by GlammyGirl Easy Application!
I absolutly LOVE this product. I love the glittery look and the bold color. It glides on very smoothly! Very easy to apply and I dont have to check my makeup every 20 minutes! I apply it in the morning and when I go to bed its still perfect. It even stays on my waterline which is amazing! The downfall to this product is the pencil itself, its very hard to sharpen!! it breaks off and leaves sharp edges that can poke you while applying. Hoping to find a better way to sharpen, I dont want to waste half the product trying to get a clean sharpen. And the product is hard to remove (which isnt all bad as it means it stays put!)
Overall I love this eyeliner! Perfect for smokey eyes and dramatic looks, but can also be simple and stunning!
Rated 5 out of 5 by Shoppily Best eyeliner i ever had
This product is awesome in color.. it reallly adds the DRAMATIC effect and makes your eyes stand out.. It does smudge over time but it aiight because it adds like a smoky effect in a cool way.
Rated 5 out of 5 by mzrozzy Eye pencil glides without tugging on lower eyelid
Excellent and bright colors !! Easy to remove with just soap and water.
Rated 2 out of 5 Not the best.
This smears easily. Like REALLY easily. After like 15-20 minutes it already smears.
Rated 5 out of 5 by itsCheryl Effective Tip for Sharpening
I absolutely love the shimmer of the silver liner and am disappointed they haven't made a self sharpening version of this liner. However, all is well, if one remembers how to 'peel it backwards' with a sharp knife, or simply do not allow a pencil sharpener to dig too deep. The core is very soft and will break if one is not careful.
Rated 3 out of 5 by Alesia Shimmery smooth pencil goes on smoothly most of the time. Did get hard and crumbly from being used over eye shadow. The colors are somewhat muted. This pencil really doesn't belong with the HIP collection because its not very pigmented, and the intense pigment color is what this collection is about. Another problem I had with it was fading. Usually HIP make up is non stop color. It also did smudge and run, and it smudged somewhat mildly. To me this is an average product that needs revamped to better suit the HIP collection and to stay fade proof and stay, period.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Susu678 I wouldn't recommend this to anyone. This is not metallic, it is eyeliner with glitter.
Rated 5 out of 5 by MICA ADDICT LOVE this! Have several colors - my fave is a tawny-bronze that's almost flesh-toned (not listed here). These are soft & last all day - the silver & gold are GREAT highlighters on your lower lash line.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Bryanna by Bryanna :)
I love this silver lightning eyeliner. I use it 24/7 all day every day , I just hate how I can only find it at a pharamacy. Walmart stopped carrying it and it really is disapointing :(.
Rated 3 out of 5 by Alesia Not very shiny or bright
Seemed like it would work but fades, and isn't true to color. Staying power is decent but won't really last day without touch up.
Rated 5 out of 5 by eatduzt I
this is my favorite eyeliner! It goes on really easy and stays on all day. The sad thing is that I can't find it anymore here in Albuquerque. That makes me sad. =( But I still love the eyeliner.
Rated 2 out of 5 by thunderfourfoxe cannot sharpen,had only a few days use
loved the product but only got a few days use from it.A lot of money for such a small amount
Rated 5 out of 5 by ToffeeChips19 Bold Fierce Color!!!
The Studio Secrets Color Chrome Eyeliner is the BEST! The pencil glides on so smoothly. And the color is so rich and bold. I got the Chrome
Rated 2 out of 5 last only one month
the color is great and it does last for once a day application but is not worth the money because it only has life of 3 weeks
Rated 5 out of 5 by MARV JUST WHAT I'VE BEEN LOOKING FOR!
THIS IS GREAT. IT IS VERY EASY TO USE LOVE THE RICH CREME FORMULA. THE COLOR IS VERY BOLD. I USED IT TO HIGHLIGHT THE INNER PART OF MY EYES AND IT STAYED PUT ALL DAY. GOING TO PURCHASE ALL COLORS.
Rated 1 out of 5 Worst Eyeliner Ever
There is NO chrome finish as advertised. Most importantly, this eyeliner might go on like liquid eyeliner but it is impossible to sharpen. The eyeliner itself literally falls apart when applied or sharpened. I have wasted more of the pencil than that of which I have been able to use. Perhaps if Loreal made this a 'self-sharpening' tool it may be more effective. That would not solve the issue of the lack of 'chrome' effect it claims to have. Waste of my money. Great disappointment from Loreal.
Rated 1 out of 5 by InFlorida Could only use 3 times
This product is a complete rip off because there is no way to sharpen this pencil. Whatever is sticking out of the top of this pencil is all you get. Of course you cant' figure that out until after you buy it and open it up.
Rated 2 out of 5 Is there a way to sharpen it?
The eyeliner pencil is ok...but I can't sharpen it. I've used it about 3 times and now it's obsolete. I've looked all over the internet and haven't found a way to sharpen it. It's really hard for me to believe that a product was made that can only be used a few times before I have to throw it away. I'm very dissapointed.
Rated 1 out of 5 Bad product.
Too thick. Loses color after you sharpen it. The tip just falls right off. Overall it's a bad product.
Rated 1 out of 5 by pgh87 Love the shade but disappointed in product.
There is no way to sharpen this pencil. Therefore I could only use it like three times! I loved the shade, but it is just not worth the money. So disappointing.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Parabola Gorgeous!
This pencil is so soft, and so pigmented, there's nothing to hate about it! This color gold is so flattering on all eye colors and skin tones.
Rated 2 out of 5 by KK814 great color only until you have to sharpen it
Love the color and the first few applications are great. Goes on smooth but you cannot sharpen this pencil. The eyeliner falls apart once you sharpen it, it becomes too soft so when you go to apply it it goes on glopy and way too thick. There is no way to sharpen it to a fine point.
I would welcome any tips on how to fix this but so far nothing works which is a shame because I love the color.
Rated 4 out of 5 by Jennifer Great Eyeliner with true color
I love the color, the ease of use and it stays on ALL day.
The only drwaback that I have experienced is sharpening the pencil. I prefer a medium thin application so I do like to ensure my eyeliner pencil is fairly pointed. I purchased two different sharpeners and neither one was able to sharpen the pencil as I would like. The outer part of the pencil appears to hard and won't let the sharpener turn an entire turn without shredding. The actual eyeliner appears to soft and breaks.
Rated 4 out of 5 by Birdlady MISS THE BLUE
EASY TO APPLY LASTS ALL DAY
Rated 4 out of 5 Surprise Surprise
While ive always been looking for a suitable silver eyeliner since the discontinuation of Bonnie Bells Silver eyeliner I was happy to buy this product. Unfortunatly this product burnt my eyes and made them water profuseley. I love it and it glides on smooth so its something you would love, if you dont mind checking your makeup every 20 minutes.
And despite the watery eyes the makeup doesnt smudge or run which is a plus. however it kinda seems it was MADE to do that. =/
Rated 5 out of 5 BY FAR THE BEST EYELINER I HAVE EVER USED!
The HIP chrome eyeliners are all around perfect. They go on so smoothly, they do not crease, (which is a promblem I have w/ typical eyeliner) the colors are great.. I have this eyeliner in 2 shades. Silver lightning, which is my favorite, and Violet ... could be a little darker, but I still really like it as well. I would recommend this for day time or evening.. it goes with anything depending on how you use it. I love it.
Rated 5 out of 5 Great application
This is one of the easiest eyeliners to apply I have ever used. Just glides on so smoothly. Be careful though cause it can go on heavy. Just a little blending and a light hand and a great liner.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Melodi30t I do like this color
I really love this color but I am afraid that I do have to say that it burned my eyes. My eyes watered and burned really strong. I am not usually sensitive to make up either.
Rated 4 out of 5 Perfect Color
This product is great. I have it the purple shade. It's awesome, highly pigmented and stuff, but you have to make sure you dont put it on too thick, which makes you look like a crazy person or something. Also, I think that the price is a little high for the product, but then again most L'Oreal products are. Overall, this is a product to buy!
Rated 5 out of 5 by Brie Eye Brightening Color
Since I'm 70 I use just a dot of this color right above the pupil of my eye. I get a nice eye brightening and wide awake look when I apply the color in this manner. Those of us with older faces need good color applied well to achieve the desired effect.