Rated 3 out of 5 by 7
Rated 2 out of 5 by EnchantedDaisy I couldn't get this to work
I hope I just got a defective one (because I love the rest of this line so much that I don't want it to have this blemish!).
I bought this in brown but I never got the product to come out. I swiped, swirled, shook, pressed, but nothing ever came out.
I will comment that the tip was a nice size and graduated so you could get a nice fine line or go thicker and bolder. I also liked the packaging as it was pretty and easy to hold.
Rated 2 out of 5 by mamacitainpa Jury is still out...
I bought this after loving all my other experiences with the Flower line, and I have to say I'm not that happy with this one. I bought the Brown and I figured that it would be a nice medium to dark brown color like the cap on the liner shows however it comes out such a pale brown that it's barely noticeable. I'm hoping that it's just a matter of the product sitting for some time so I'm going to return and edit this post if the color ever gets darker. If it doesn't, I would go for the black and give that a whirl as I'm in love with the applicator...very easy to use!
Rated 5 out of 5 by jelloshooters This eye liner is amazing! It truly does last all day long and no smuges. Its so easy to apply.
Rated 2 out of 5 by CPC1 A little disappointed :(
I am an old school, cake eyeliner person. I thought I'd try this to see if I could go for a little more dramatic cat eye for evenings. I find this to be on the dry side and I have to go back over areas where it missed. It doesn't stay on me well, it gets crumbly. I wish the application was smoother and had a more lasting result, I can control a tiny brush more easily. Disappointed.
Rated 4 out of 5 by piccolena Smudge Free
I have spent lots of $$ trying to find a good liquid eyeliner and this is almost perfect. With other liquid eyeliner, I find that by the end on the day, it has smudged to my bottom lid. The color is nice and dark, my only wish would be that the tip of the brush was more brush like than marker like. I can't get the cat eye look that I want because of the tip of the brush. Just takes longer to apply than if it were more like a paint brush.
Rated 1 out of 5 by snuphee High hopes meet by disappointment
I was looking for a liquid eyeliner and thought hey let's try something new. I am very loyal to one brand but thought why not. Got home opened up the package and tried it on. I got the Black. Smoothed it on my lid but was not black, more of a brown color, and had to re-apply and re-apply to get the black to even show. After about three blinks of the eye the color was on my eyelid crease. Sad face. So I thought maybe I need to warm it up a bit so rolled it between my hands but still nothing. Now I know why I am loyal to one brand.
Rated 5 out of 5 by ChicSF Great liner, great price
I was skeptical about how good this product was going to be...and was happily impressed! It goes on smoothly, with a rich black color and stays on all day!