Rated 4.6 out of 5★ by 16reviewers.
Rated 5 out of 5★ by SuFroIda A Classic I grew up with this book and remember reading it as a child.I have also read it to all 4 of my kids when they were babies and they have all just LOVED it. My 3rd kid trashed the book so had to buy a replacement for my 10 month old. It has quickly become one of his favorites. All babies seem to love the ring that they can stick their finger into.I wish they made a more indestructible board-book version because it really doesn't hold up to much, but I still think it is worth buying. 08/27/2009
Rated 4 out of 5★ by rablf Teacher recommended This book was recommended to me by a school teacher who has a two year old and one on the way. She said this is the book to have so I bought it and I put it in my new one month old grandson's stocking for Christmas. Time will tell if she is right. His mother reads to him often as this is supposed to make him a lifelong reader. 12/27/2013
Rated 3 out of 5★ by CSCG Buy the hardcover! Good interactive book for children but I would recommend that you buy the hardcover instead. The paperback edition is just ring-binded, i don't think it will last. I am not sure if this book is really scented because mine is. There is a strong perfume smell. When you get to the page "Paul can smell the flowers" probably you should not ask your child to "now You smell the flowers"... 05/18/2010