Rated 2.4 out of 5 by 48
Rated 1 out of 5 by Sabrina_S SMUDGES
Smudges like crazy, it won't even last right after I apply it, the worst liner I've ever used.
Rated 3 out of 5 by tclark211 Has formula changed? Having allergic reaction ...
I've been using the define-a-line eyeliner pencil for years, but now I'm having an allergic reaction within a few hours of putting it on. At least three times now I've opened a new eyeliner and within hours start having symptoms similar to conjunctivitis (itching, burning, red, mucus that keeps coming back). I thought maybe there is some coating that I'm reacting to because it always happens after I first use a new one, so I opened one today, used a napkin to hopefully get past the coating, then applied. Now, a few hours later I'm having the symptoms again. Did they change something about the formula recently??? I love the way it goes on, but it does smear easily, and now with this reaction I will have to switch brands.
Rated 4 out of 5 by AquaMarie Yes, It does smudge...
It does smudge. But personally, I love it. And the pencil is really nice. You can make nice thick lines; or nice thin lines.
Rated 4 out of 5 by Skyler A Good Beginner Product.
I like this product because of how thick and easy it is to use. It does not smear for me because I am so particular but it doesn't last forever! Personally I don't need it for long, so I still like it!
Rated 2 out of 5 by 3yearsofroses Smudges
This smudges HORRIBLY, which wouldn't be a big deal except it does so all day long. The little bit remaining on my eyes when I get home is all contributing to "raccoon eyes." I had to find a new brand of eyeliner.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Nhop1 The WORST Product... by your biggest FAN
You don't need the smudger... just wait two seconds and it will SMUDGE all over your FACE! Take this product off the market - PLEASE! It's giving MAYBELLINE a bad name. I love your products and have been happy for over a decade... PLEASE perfect this or let it GO!!! I want my money back!
Rated 1 out of 5 by clsellers88 smears...
dislike how it smears terribly! like how it glides on for perfect eyes.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Lette913 Love it!
I love this eyeliner. The smudger always falls off the end on the first use, please fix this.
Rated 4 out of 5 by bnich02 Classic Eyeliner
I have used this eyeliner for years. It is great for a bold, thick eyeliner. I however have problems with smudging or running. If you use it on your top lid only with eyeshadow that will minimize the running. I don't recommend for bottom lashes. But it's a classic, tried and true! 4 Stars for Smudging.
Rated 1 out of 5 by mamamarcie Smudges Everywhere!
I apply it, and it smudges. I look like I have two black eyes!
Rated 4 out of 5 by Wintersangel32 Smooth to apply, but smudges.
It was greatly dark, went on super smoothly. I wish it didn't smudge as badly. Waterproof version, please? :)
Rated 1 out of 5 Terrible Mascara
This is one of the worst eyeliners I have ever used. The color of it is very rich and black, but that is the only good thing about it. I used it to tightline my upper lash line, and for the rest of the day it is literally smudging off onto my undereye area. I have rarely used any products in my life that give 'raccoon eyes.'I even tried putting UDPP (eye shadow primer) under my eyes and a lot of eyeshadow to try and keep it in place, but NOTHING helps. Really disappointing because I tend to like Maybelline products a lot. This eyeliner is terrible, terrible, terrible. I'm going to just end up throwing it out.
Rated 5 out of 5 by anj5035 Bold
If you want a bold, rich eyeliner, then this is the eyeliner for you! I absolutely love this product, it makes my eyes pop and lasts all day! Also, the smooth application and consistency of the product makes it easy to apply.
Rated 1 out of 5 by NicciF If you want to look like a raccoon...
I bought this eyeliner because it was the only black eye liner the store had that day. I should have just waited for them to restock the kind I normally get. It goes on easily, but comes off just as easily. Every time I wear it I have to constantly check it because it runs worse than any eye liner I have ever had. Unless you want black smudges under your eyes making you look like you belong in a horror movie, I'd stay away from this eye liner.
Rated 3 out of 5 by Lola It was ok...
This was a pretty good liner but i got raccoon eyes by the end of the day :/
Rated 1 out of 5 by anonomus disappointed
I bought this liner because it was available in Sapphire. This liner is not long wearing as the package states. It ran after only a short time of wearing. So disappointed!
Rated 5 out of 5 by luz928 bought it for my 17 yr old. and she loved it.