Rated 4.2 out of 5 by 100
Rated 4 out of 5 by pinkrain2010 Not bad, but not excellent
It goes on nicely, but throughout the day it smears and I look like I have two black eyes.
Rated 3 out of 5 by nicki10 I've Used Better
I had high hopes for this liner. But just this morning I tried to use it. You have to push fairly hard for it to go on, and since it's sharpened when you get it, it hurts! I just put it down and went back to my old liner, which glided on, but for me the line was too thin. I like CoverGirl's products, but this just did not work for me. Maybe if it was more dull you could tollerate pressing the pencil so that you're not scratching your eye up.
Rated 4 out of 5 by nyvagram "Raising eyebrows" when I choose
As I've moved along in senior years, my eyebrows have decided to become as curly as my hair. When I tweeze out the unruly ones, the result is little bald spots in the natural shape. This pencil allows me to restore appearance of previous density and shape. While my hair is almost completely gray, with some white, the eyebrows only lightened a little from their original near-black; so I chose the charcoal color to soften the contrast. I'm pleased with the choice.
The pencil is soft enough to allow smooth application. However, the point does round very quickly, so perhaps a built-in sharpener would be the one thing that would make this a more perfect product for me.
Rated 5 out of 5 by MoeBlw Great!! Nice blending stick!!
Rated 5 out of 5 by DOLLIESHOME I WAS USING MAYBELLENE BEFORE
TRYED THIS COVER GIRL EYELINER AND LIKED IT SO MUCH MORE THAN MAYBELLINE EYELINER IT DOSENT SMUDGE AS MUCH AS THE MAYBELLINE SO WILL CONTINUE BUYING COVER GIRL
Rated 5 out of 5 by Citcat22 Great Eyeliner
I would never use another Eyeliner this goes on smooth and lasts awhile!!!
Rated 5 out of 5 by Lovinghusband Stock up
Now my wife does not have to buy them for a long time
Rated 5 out of 5 by Betty Love it
I love this product it lasts all day
Rated 5 out of 5 Best eyeliner ever
This Was my absolute favorite eyeliner for about 20 years.I had started trying others, including urban decay's 24/7 and forgot all about this wonderful product. Picked 1 up the other day and IT IS THE BEST! I will NEVER EVER use anything else.
Rated 4 out of 5 by Beaus Use it for eyebrows!
This pencil may not be the best for eye lining, but it is great for my skimpy brows! I could never find the right color or application for my fading eye brows. I found this liner in smokey taupe and fell in love with how great it works for brows.
Rated 5 out of 5 by clues5 Wide Awake Eyes
This pencil is easy to apply, no tugging, no waiting for it to soften up. It goes on smooth, easy and makes your eyes look big and bright. The price is right. Walmart is the best place to get it, the delivery is cheaper than driving to get it. Thanks Walmart
Rated 5 out of 5 I love this eyeliner and have already recommended it to a friend who also likes it. It goes on very smoothly although it is easily smudged. It will last me from morning to night without fading much but being set with a similarly colored eye shadow is very beneficial. Another con is that it needs to be sharpened daily or every other day to keep the tip sharp. Overall I'm sure I'll repurchase it.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Rawr great, so far:)
I bought this eyeliner 2 days ago and ive only used it twice, but i love it already:) i wear it on my bottom waterline and it stays on for awhile! i havent sharpened it yet, but there shouldnt be a problem when i do. great buy:)!
Rated 2 out of 5 by emmacakes eh..probably wouldn't buy again.
It went on smoothly, but it is not water resistant what so ever. Pretty disappointed in the product. Won't buy again.
Rated 1 out of 5 by xograce07xo Melts right off
I have somewhat oily eyelids, so this product seemed to melt off after only a few hours. I have this product in navy and grey, and I like the vibrantness of the navy, but the grey doesn't show up. The blending end is great for creating a pretty line.
Rated 5 out of 5 by CrysLd simple, classic, perfect
this is amazing eyeliner. I remember when I was little, my mom used to always use this. I think it's a lot better than CG's perfect point plus based on the fact that it lasts longer & the tip doesn't break off as easily. very durable. good stuff.
Rated 5 out of 5 by JolieRouge The old standby!
I love this eyeliner, and have been using it for decades. Sharpened it can give crisp lines, or smudged out for smoky effect. So versatile! Creamy formula goes on easily. I've tried others thinking I'd find a better traditional pencil to no avail.
Rated 5 out of 5 by MrsTeacher Nice and simple
I don't usually wear liner because I don't really know how to apply it. I got this because it seemed like a simple liner to practice with. It goes on smoothly and blends well. I'd definitely buy this again.
Rated 4 out of 5 by CoverGurlLuver7 Really good, not exactly great, though
I got this eyeliner today. The color is great, looks good & goes on smooth without tugging or pulling at your eyes. The "blender" works well with getting more of a smoky eye & i dab makeup remover on it to erase my mistakes at the bottom of my eyes.
Rated 3 out of 5 by LittleMarie Happy, not exhilarated
I put on this and it looked great on me. At first I was not sure about the blending, but it turned out to be fine. I absolutely love how this pencil is a lot easier to sharpen, the only thing is it doesn't flatter well. I am still very happy with it.
Rated 3 out of 5 by CarrieCircaSeason3 Descent but not Hot
The pencil hasn't broke on me when applying or sharpening. Smudger works well. Pencil drags along lash line, isn't very creamy and doesn't blend that well. Feels like a regular #2 school pencil near my eye. Will buy another drugstore brand in future.
Rated 4 out of 5 by EmilyW I really like this. I do not wear a ton of makeup, but this pencil would also be great for someone who does because it can make a thin line or a thicker one. Another thing I love about it - it doesn't break AND it sharpens easily!
Rated 4 out of 5 by breakfastattiffanys This won't break easily when sharpening, but as a trade off it doesn't glide very smoothly on the eyelid, feels like a regular #2 school pencil instead of makeup. I'd recommend Perfect Point Plus instead: glides smoothly, has smudger, self-sharpens.
Rated 5 out of 5 by WHolman Great pencil eyeliner!
I really like this. I use it on my bottom eyes. It' blends easy and stays on all day long. Even on the waterline!
Rated 3 out of 5 by Ellie101 Great For Smokey Eye!
You choose the right colors you can really have your eyes pop! This has a great blending tool for smokey eyes.
Rated 5 out of 5 by mel1985 GREAT BROW PENCIL!!!
I have been using the charcoal colored pencil on my brows for years. If you have hair so brown that it is almost black, it is hard to find a matching color, the browns are too light and the blacks are too dark. Give it a try and you will love it!
Rated 5 out of 5 by Margerydoll CG'sBest!
Not only is this Covergirl's best, it beats any brand I've tried, even expensive ones. I am never trying anything else again, so keep making black-brown!
Rated 4 out of 5 by mcjaymi95 I Love It
I love it. It's smooth, doesn't pull or tug (which is a biggy for me), lasts all day, doesn't smudge, and looks great. Eyeliner Lovers: BUY BUY BUY!
Rated 5 out of 5 by Regan ~10 years and Counting~
I've been using this eyeliner for ten years and counting now and it is the best eyeliner at the best price I've yet to find. It goes on smooth, it's consistently good quality and it lasts all day.
Rated 5 out of 5 by lalalalala SWEET eyeliner
I have used this since i started wearing makeup and its by far the best. it doesnt smudge and it goes on VERY smoothly. It last the whole day and goes great in my waterline.