Rated 4.4 out of 5 by 53
Rated 5 out of 5 by xxStellaxx Great!
I love this! Absolutely great! It's great for filling in eye brows. I don't really use it as an eye liner. More like a brow pencil then eye pencil. I just wish it had a brush on it so you can brush out your brows when you're done filling them in. Anyway, I love this!
Rated 5 out of 5 by iloveaffordablemakeup Works best as a filler
Love this product! Works best as an eyebrow filler, not as an eyeliner. Great color-matches perfectly with my eyebrows. Best and affordable filler I have used thus far!
Rated 3 out of 5 by JULSNYC :)
I purchased these from Walmart.com because they are alittle more expensive in the stores by me ..
Rated 5 out of 5 by ETR2015 AWESOME
I have used this product for 35 years and will continue to use it. Perfect eyeliner! Simply pass the pencil through a flame gently and allow to cool. Perfect eyeliner every time!
Rated 3 out of 5 by Emily Really hard
The color choice is poor. Also, the liner itself is on the hard side so you have to put more pressure on it to apply it. It makes it hard to go for a more natural look.
Rated 5 out of 5 by CPM Color choice
Please advise what happened to the color charcoal in brow pencil, a few years ago it was rated the best color on the market for brows and now I cannot find it anywhere Is it available and if not why would you stop producing the product voted # 1 ?
Rated 5 out of 5 by NancyH Thanks
Thanks for bringing this back. It is the only eye brow pencil that I like. I was hoarding my last one, but then found it in Walmart. I bought all four in stock, in case I didn't see any again.
Rated 5 out of 5 by kris Awesome!
Easy to use. Good, quality.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Amyre Ashley Please Please......
Please do not discontinued this product i absolutely love this eyebrow pencil i love easily i can fill in my brows
Rated 5 out of 5 by ESOLOMON7712 OUT with the NEW, IN with the OLD!
Please bring the old stuff back, I've been using it for 10+ years, and suddenly can't find it anywhere!! So far, I haven't found anything that compares! If I can find a comparable product with ANY company, I'd gladly buy it, no matter the cost!
Rated 5 out of 5 by michellemm BRING IT BACK
I've used this since I started wearing make up because it stays on all day and goes on easily. I cant find it anywhere!
WHY would they get rid of something so well-loved?
Rated 5 out of 5 by marco565 Do not discontinue.
I work long shifts in a large hospital. This product has been my tried ( I've tried them all), and true eyeliner of all time. I'm 48. 35 years I've used this. It works. It lasts. Don't lose customers. Keep this, it's too good to discontinue. Thanks.
Rated 5 out of 5 by CsThRuH2O I❤eyebrows
...because I don't have any, at least my natural ones are not very full and not very visable by much. I always define my natural brow line and resculpt my eyebrows. Even on low mainteance days I have to have my eyebrows done.
Rated 5 out of 5 by packard As good as high priced kind
I was using a pencil that was 4x the price because they claimed it was long lasting. This product is just as good. The old Mayb pencils dtied out & needed sharpening. This one is thin and moist. My brows look less 'drawn on' than the old style
Rated 5 out of 5 by Paula Roland Wyard-Scott please bring original product back
I absolutely loved this product and have used it for 30yrs or as long as it has been out there... please bring this back as I have wasted hundreds of dollars trying to find a comparable product and its not gonna happen.
Rated 4 out of 5 by Kissing Potion The Holy Grail of Eyeliners
This was the first eyeliner I used back when I was just starting out with makeup over 34 years ago. This stays put but you have to warm it before application because as a liner, it's not easy to apply if you don't. That said it does last all day.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Cathy Whittier Why?
Why remove a tried & true product, the old expert wear twin brow& eye pencil. After searching forever for sharpeners I find out it is discontinued. After using for 25 years I will have to find another company as your new ones are no good.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Carolyn1947 Please bring back product
I used the previous version from a very young age because of an accident and I lost an eyebrow. I was maybe 12 yrs old so for over 54 yrs I used your product. The replacement is subpar. It breaks when sharpened and when you try to use it. Help! Plz!!
Rated 5 out of 5 by Momof2beauty Best Eyeliner After Decades
My mother, in her 70's, have been using this eyeliner for over 40 years. I have purchased everything from MAC to Loreal and always go back to the Maybelline Expert Wear eyeliner. It blends perfectly for eyebrows and lasts all day for eyeliner, even in hot humid weather. No smudging, no creases, no fading. To get the smokey eye look, I heat the pencil up a little with my breath (yes...the same way you like to see your breath cloud outdoors on a cold winter day) and it goes on smooth and more intense.
Rated 5 out of 5 by sparklplenti My favorite eyeliner/brow pencil
I've used it for over 20 years, as has my mother before me. I keep one in every purse, bag, bathroom. It's easy to use, lasts, & is simply a staple for me. I'm disappointed it's apparently gone/going away.
Rated 5 out of 5 by a209659 Unbelievable
I love this liner! I have used it since I started wearing makeup over 35 years ago. My mom has used it all of her life also. It goes on smoothly, looks nice, & lasts all day. I'm so disappointed!
Rated 5 out of 5 by Campingshadow Please bring it back
I used this product for many years and was entirely happy with it. It was taken off the market and the replacement is horrible. Does anyone in the company read these reviews? Bring this back!!!! Don't you care about your customers?
Rated 5 out of 5 by harry The Best
This is the best eyebrow product on the market. We have used this since the 70's. Perfect color . Easy to use. Who made the huge error in deciding to take it off the product list. It seems to me that when you read all the reviews you would certainly decide to keep it. Otherwise your loyal consumers of many years will have to start exploring competitors products. Please rethink this decision.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Astonishing Where are my FAVOURITE pencils???
I've loved using the classic Maybelline eyebrown pencils for over 15 years.The new design is 1) far too soft & thick for brows & 2) has nowhere near the longevity of the former classic 'red' pencils. Why change something that was not broken? DISASTER
Rated 2 out of 5 by cac1937 Where's the AUBURN?
I've been wearing your auburn eyebrow color for more years than I can remember and now I can't find it at all! I tried the pencil you used to replace the original auburn and it's awful! Please bring back the old one. Redheads need you!!
Rated 5 out of 5 by Jsscmurray5 Eyebrow
I use this pencil for my eyebrows and after spending months trying to find the perfect eyebrow pencil I found this! I love it.
Rated 5 out of 5 by ShortHairedGirl Two for one? Bring it on!
This product was recommended by a friend, so I wanted to give it a go. I purchased this in blonde, at Target. Fills in the gaps, doesn't look overdone, durable, and because the outside coat is red, it doesn't get confused with my eyeliner. I love it!
Rated 5 out of 5 by sharonw desparate
I've been using your Charcoal Grey eyebrow pencil since I was 15...born blonde, eyebrows never visible..your Charcoal grey eye pencil was perfect for outlining and shaping my eyebrows to look natural...no other color works for me!! can't believe the panic of not finding it on the shelves...searched everywhere from Alberta Canada, Honolulu and all six states where our children reside! PLEASE..don't you have some leftover stock somewhere for me to purchase? I'm wasting my money trying to find a replacement...from you and your competition.Help!
Rated 4 out of 5 by abgib ExpertWear Brow and Eye Pencil
I have used this product since I was in high school but the one that I used did not have the built-in sharpener. I used the charcoal color and loved it. For me, the color was perfect. Please, please bring back the charcoal color!
Rated 5 out of 5 by califgirl44 Why?????
I have used this eyebrow pencil for over 30 years and I have tried many others, but none compare. I have red hair so the browns will not do. I can't find it in my color anywhere. Why did you discontinue it???? Please bring it back Maybelline!