Rated 4.1 out of 5 by 57
Rated 5 out of 5 by PunchBuggy79 so far, so good.
I'm not picky when it comes to make-up. Just so long as it looks good and doesn't double my grocery bill to buy. Mascara is the only make-up I wear some days (blonde lashes, so it's a MUST). So far, this one works well. It's not so crazy thick that you look like a 13-year-old who is excited about finally being allowed to wear make-up. But enough to make you look like you did something to get ready to leave the house this morning. I didn't realize it was water proof, until it arrived. I don't normally like water proof mascaras, but it was actually a good mistake. Now I don't look like a member a Kiss when I leave the gym, after a day at work. Stays on well, but comes off completely and easily with mild soap. (I usually use plain Ivory liquid hand-soap)
Rated 5 out of 5 by lwhitegirl My new favorite mascara
looks great & no raccoon eyes. Doesn't get clumpy even if you don't remove it every day.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Sylvernight My favorite mascara
This is my favorite mascara. It is a good color--not too brown, but not quite black, and it makes my lashes look good. It is definitely waterproof, so make sure you have a good make-up remover.
Rated 5 out of 5 by jmjp Works great for sensitive eyes
i have a hard time with mascara and my sensitive eyes, also with smearing above and below my eyes. this product works great for me, will buy over and over, no smearing, no allergy to product.
Rated 1 out of 5 by Cupcake03 Not for me
I couldn't use this Mascara. Flaked off, making my eyes itch.
Rated 5 out of 5 by bettbett1 It's as good as Marathon mascara
This mascara is just as good as Marathon mascara. When they discontinued Marathon I couldn't find any mascaras that were truly waterproof, even though they claimed they were. When I bought this mascara I intended on taking it back if it wasn't waterproof. I'm happy to say this mascara can hold up to 90 plus degree heat & humidity. I wear hard contact lenses & under eye concealer & have never had a problem. Thank you Neutrogena!
Rated 2 out of 5 by peaches6 my mascara
The Mascara didn't work how I thought it was going to work..I'm better off getting the same one I normally get from Walmart..
Rated 5 out of 5 by sara s Comparable to Diorshow
I love Diorshow mascara, but since it's so expensive, I alternate buying/using it with drugstore mascara. I usually try a different brand each time, but Healthy Volume is so far the BEST I've found- I haven't gotten a different kind since.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Texas gal Does what it says!
Picky, picky, picky... I am so picky about my mascara. Love the volume, not too much but nice enough to see the difference from other mascaras. No tearing eyes from harsh ingredients. And wow, a bargain too.
Rated 5 out of 5 by wrb91 Super mascara!
This stuff is awesome. I use two coats, curling lashes before each coat. I love the thick, voluminous look this mascara gives my lashes.
Rated 4 out of 5 by HeeyGirl19 Get the fake lash look!
I love dramatic looking lashes. I like mine thick and long, similar to the drama false lashes give. BUT I would never wear falsies, so this was a great find! This makes my lashes really stand out. Washes off easily with water and soap, so no more having to accidently pull my lashes out trying to take off the mascara!
Rated 5 out of 5 by andeedeeh Amazing length and volume!
This mascara is by far the best mascara available in drugstores... and I have tried MANY. It adds amazing volume and length, and you can keep adding coats without clumping! I also love it because it is nourishing my eyelashes- they never fall off when taking it off at night. I was having a problem were I lost 3 to 5 eyelashes per night and I didn't know what to use! THIS IS AMAZING.
Rated 2 out of 5 by Diana8607 Sorry, But this did nothing for my lashes!
I was hoping I finally found a mascara I liked, but this did nothing for my lashes. I mean I keep sweeping and sweeping and it did not stay on lashes. It did not even add lengh.
Rated 4 out of 5 by Mims Mascera
Ordering this mascara straight from Neutrogena instead of getting it at the store works much better for me. Almost always when I get it through the store, it is already dried up and I end up buying a new tube every couple of weeks. This tube that I ordered from the manufacturer has been great! Still wet and glides on well and curls my lashes as it advertises. If all the stores could guantee the freshness of this product, it would be sold out all the time. I love this mascara and believe me, I have tried most all of the expensive brands and this is the best by far.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Angielovemylife It makes your lashes REALLY Long!
One thing I found out was the bigger the brush, the bigger the lashes. Not only is the brush much bigger than other brands the mascara itself is thicker but not too thick. I hope they never stop making it. This mascara makes my eyelashes look much longer and much fuller too!
Rated 5 out of 5 by LouLou Love It
Makes my lashes look so full and long...did not clump.
Rated 5 out of 5 Rich color, naturally full look
I've tried dozens of mascaras and this is my favorite overall mascara. The black-brown shade is a rich mocha color and truly makes my eyes seem more green and standout more. (More so than some brands I've tried that claim to do that on their packaging.) It doesn't flake off, and there's minimal clumping even after several coats. It provides a natural looking fullness to lashes. Lashes always feel soft and flexible. It never smudges or runs if I rub my eyes. It not irritating to sensitive eyes. It doesn't give tons of dramatic looking volume, so be aware if that's what your looking for. It starts off kind of on the wetter side (as opposed to drier side) for those who know what I'm talking about, but each tube gets better with use. I'll definitely re-purchase this mascara many times.
Rated 5 out of 5 by sEdge FINALLY! the perfect mascara!!!
After all these years of settling for "the next new best thing" in the mascara realm, I believe this one is the best by far I've ever tried! I'll even go as far to say that it bests out the expensive department store cosmetics! It truly does not flake, stays on all day and never clumps! I truly feel as though the olive oil comes in to play when removing. It no longer feels like im ripping out my eyelashes!! If your still searching for the perfect mascara... Look no further
Rated 5 out of 5 by Aggiesmom2 It is easy to apply and trouble free.
I always have trouble with clumping mascara. This one went on easily and clump free. Love it and will buy it all the time from now on.
Rated 5 out of 5 by NeutrogenaFreak001 So Much Fuller!
This is an Amazing product for eyelashes. Does not clump at all, and makes your eyelashes look so much fuller! I started to notice that after about a week of applying it that my eyelashes were become thicker and thicker, which is exactly what I wanted!! Best mascara that you will EVER use!
Rated 5 out of 5 by Mustang2010 So natural looking!!
I have lashes that clump easly and it's a challenge to find a mascara that doesn't look overwhelming. This gives me subtle volume and looks very natural this will be my mascara for life! Finally I found something that does what it says
Rated 4 out of 5 by texas gal My lashes look and feel so good
I have used every known brand of mascara from affordable to very expensive and was pleasantly surprised at how well this worked. it did not bother my eyes. did not smell harsh and stayed on very well. it is very similar to Dior Dior Show mascara but at the fraction of the cost. I would recommend trying it.
Rated 3 out of 5 by vababi09 Good for on the go!!
I love this product! It's good when I'm in a rush and I want to look polish for classes. It doesn't flake throughout the day! Overall it's a great buy :)
Rated 1 out of 5 by Simbatia Flakes
I loved Weightless Volume. This is terrible. Flakes off badly after a short time.
Rated 5 out of 5 by LovleyLashes must have mascara!
My eyelashes are naturally long, but sadly they are not very voluminous. I know I can always trust Neutrogena's cosmetics, and was happy to find this mascara. The brush is fantastic and when it dries my lashes are soft and defined. I will definitely buy again!
Rated 2 out of 5 by dodie WHERE is weightless volume?
weightless volume was terrific for those of use with contact lenses and anyone who merely wants darker, but more natural looking lashes. It was perfect. Where can I find it? (this one smudges)
Rated 1 out of 5 by changeisntalwaysgood Bring back Weightless Volume!
The only mascara I've ever loved was Weightless Volume. For a contact wearer there's nothing better! Tried this one when I couldn't fine the other and it is way too thick, smudges and flakes! Bring back Weightless Volume please!!!
Rated 4 out of 5 by Simply.nana FALSE EYELASHES , BEATS LASH BLAST!
best mascara ever , beats maybelline* and lash blast. although i put on double coats it gives me the volume that i paid for ! its not irriating at all , youll noticed a difference with other mascaras, and makes lashes full and amazingg!!
Rated 1 out of 5 by Minimilist make up user Panda Eyes
I loved the Weightless volume mascara, it never gave me panda eyes.. made me look like I had laushes but did not clump... I can't find that anywhere now and so tried this one! Back to the panda eyes again..smudges underneath my eyes within a couple of hours... back to the search for something that isn't waterproof but does not smudge all over the place :( PLEASE bring back the weightless one!
Rated 4 out of 5 by peaches great mascara
I don't like waterproof mascara and this product is just great! It goes on full and doesn't clump. Washes off fairly easily with soap and water. Best of all, the price! I previously used a name brand mascara and will not be returning to that one now that I found this one! I recommend this product!