Rated 1 out of 5 by KayyJD GROSS
This says it's oil free but after using it I feel like a greaseball. It's disgusting and tugs at your skin!
Rated 5 out of 5 by Dinamchu Great product
Is one of the best I ever used. removes every drop of waterproof mascara. Love it!
Rated 5 out of 5 by LissyLips Pricey, but worth every penny!
I've used many different kinds of makeup remover. I only wear waterproof mascara which tends to be difficult to remove, but one swipe with this stuff and it's all off. For the last two years I have only purchased this brand. Actually, I have stocked up just in case they quit making it... you never know. It says oil free, but I find it hard to believe since it works so well on waterproof mascara, but I'm not complaining. It in NO WAY leaves my skin feeling oily though. Although I ONLY use this product on my eyes. I use sensitive baby wipes for my face, it's inexpensive and it works well.
Rated 5 out of 5 by marriedarockstar Works Great!!
This is one of the best eye makeup removers I have used. It easily takes off all eye makeup, including my waterproof mascara. I have already recommended this to family and friends, and they love it too!
Pros: Great at removing tough makeup, very gentle, can be used on sensitive eyes and skin.
Cons: Vision is sometimes a little blurred right after use, but goes away quickly.
Overall, I truly do love this and hope to always have it on hand!
Rated 5 out of 5 by Alethea912 Greasy But It Works
It works and it is not too greasy. It works for other make-up, too.
Rated 1 out of 5 by TXRunner Greasy!
It's so greasy--I can't stand using it. And it does not completely remove my mascara (which is not even waterproof). After using this product, I almost always get mascara particles in my eye. Just terrible. Do not waste your money.
Rated 5 out of 5 by pinktree Best make up remover ever!!!!
I used to use CHANEL‘s and LANCOME’'s~~and found this one is the best one ever even it feels greasy, it really does its job. Also you need you use cleanser to wash your face after use this, why the greasy feel is a problem?!!??
Rated 5 out of 5 by BrownBeauty49 Best remover ever and gentle on the eyes!
I love this remover, especially after trying several others at all price points. I have eye allergies and most products bother my sensitive eyes and skin. This doesn't make my eyes sting, I can usually get the waterproof mascara off in two easy swipes. It is not oily, very pleasant scent and feel. It is hands down the only remover I will continue to use.
Rated 5 out of 5 by Annadair65 Works great!
This eye makeup remover takes it all off! Even stubborn waterproof types. It's the best I've ever used.
Rated 1 out of 5 very oily and didn't take make up off well
I do not like this product- it is oily and smelled too perfume like
Rated 5 out of 5 by dumpling08 takes of waterproof mascara
love this product, greta for taking off waterproof mascara
Rated 2 out of 5 So oily
This product really does work to wipe away your eye makeup, but it is anything but oil-free. It really leaves me feeling dirty, and weighed down.
Rated 5 out of 5 by JilliesMom Eye Makeup Remover
This eye makeup remover works just as well as Lancome, but why pay the higher price?
Rated 5 out of 5 by se20 Works Great!!
I was looking for something that removes water proof mascara. And this is the product for me. Please do not ever discontinue this product. It is just a tiny bit oily, but i just clean my eye area with warm water. And i wash my face after. So it really is no problem for me. Love it! Thanks Neutrogena Team!!
Rated 5 out of 5 love it
i love it but is a little greasy have to wash my face afterwards but overall get the job done nice and smoothly, doesn't irritate my skin at all. and it get all of my eyeliner and mascara off within the first use.
Rated 4 out of 5 by Janieh31 Please improve your opening
Would you please make the opening of you product finger length! We all spill the liquid all over because you have the opening so big! This has been forever! Just take your finger put it on the opening and waste it all over your hand! We dont use our fingers with pretty little Cotten balls to wash the make up off our face, we're too busy for that stuff! You know this to be true! When I use clinuqe they get the picture...let me buy your prouduct please but as for now I'm over it!
Rated 5 out of 5 by Satisfy Customer This product is perfect.
I love this product because on like baby oil once you used it leaves that oily residue on your eyes. Therefore, this eye makeup remover is perfect, does not irritate my skin nor leaves residue behind once you remove your makeup.
Rated 5 out of 5 by MississippiGirl Love Love Love it!!
I've tried eye makeup removers from Mary Kay to Merle Norman and this product, by far, is the BEST I've ever used. I wear waterproof mascara and this removes all traces without having to "scrub" my eyes. I've also noticed it conditions my eyelashes. The waterproof mascara usually dries them out and causes breakage but since using this I've noticed they are fuller and longer and much less breakage. This is an AMAZING product! Please don't ever discontinue!!! Thank you!!
Rated 1 out of 5 by Vaden09 It works great but so does baby oil!! After I use this on my eyes I feel disgusting but the product does work but if you like feeling a greasy monkey around your eyes by all means try this product out!!
Rated 3 out of 5 by Piyo IT IS OIL FREE
you guys.... people keep saying that it says its "oil free" but doest feel like it but... it is! it might be greasy but that doesn't mean it contains oil... it's silicon based, not oil based people!
but the reason im giving it a 3 is because its really good for removing my gel liner BUT it pulls out my eyelashes even if i dont rub, drys my eyelids (i didnt know eyelids could become dried before i used this O_O), making them feel like paper, and feels like it creates a film on my eyeballs if it goes in...
Rated 3 out of 5 Not Amazing /:
I've heard really great things about this eye makeup remover, but when I finally got a bottle for myself, it just did not live up to my expectation :(
- While it was fairly gentle, it was not effective at removing my eye makeup, including waterproof mascara. It took more effort than expected to remove everything, and I had to use quite a bit of product to do so.
- It does leave a residue, nothing too crazy, but nevertheless it left some grease behind.
- It's pricey considering how much you get and how much you need to get rid of all the eyemakeup. I wouldn't recommend this especially if you wear eyemakeup daily, as you will use up this product quickly.
On the plus side, it is relatively gentle and can get rid of eyemakeup, just not as quickly as it claimed.
Rated 4 out of 5 by meggo works good!
yes it does leave residue on skin but it says to wash with wash cloth after using. always works no doubt!
Rated 1 out of 5 by hunterjumpermakeuplover "oil-free??"
this stuff is actually so extremely greasy and oily, i took off my make up one night, and the next morning my face was really greasy. i would not ever get this again
Rated 2 out of 5 by smileyface:D greasy and oily :(
i don't understand why it says oil free... you have to shake it to get the two different liquids to mix together so nasty greasiness isnt the only thing you get on your face. i hate to use it because it leaves my face shiny and greasy
Rated 2 out of 5 by surfer101 this stuff works but it is not oil free
it always removes my eye make up but it is full of oil i bought it used it once and set it on my counter the nextday i came in all the oil had gone to the top and was floating there and it leaves olily resdius
Rated 5 out of 5 by allhannsup AMAZING stuff
I wear waterproof eye makeup everyday, and this makeup remover removes everything very well without irritation. I've tried other makeup removers, but I keep coming back to this one. I don't see myself using any other makeup remover. Hope they don't discontinue.
Rated 5 out of 5 Effective, mild and financially responsible
Incredibly effective, cheap and readily available. A great product!
Rated 5 out of 5 by PrettyLashes Love It!
I personally only wear macara, but I always transition from a waterproof and a non-waterproof brands and i have found that this is the only remover I can use that get everything off on the first try! I have experimented with other removers in the past but was never satisfied because either it would sting my eyes and cause irration or it would never get everything off, even after multiple tries. I have recommended this product to friends who wear a lot of eye makeup and they are all still using it and love it! When I use this product I never have a problem with eye irration even when I need to get my bottom lashes with a Q-tip! Excellent, I love it!!!
Rated 5 out of 5 by Sara Finally an eye makeup remover I can use!
I've had a lot of difficulty finding an eye-makeup remover that doesn't irritate my eyes. Even expensive ones that promised to be very gentle left my eyes stinging well into the next morning. This product by Neutrogena is the first I've found that I can actually use! It leaves my eyes feeling as though they're slightly dry, but this is tolerable and much much better then what products from other companies do. Thank you Neutrogena!
Rated 5 out of 5 by miller4511 skin so soft & i look younger !
I love this product, lived at beach got the roughest skin & don't know what I'd do without it.